Child Care Task Force
Members Present:
Sen. Leonard Blackham, Chair
Rep. Sheryl Allen, Chair
Sen. Pete Suazo
Julie Baker
Melinda Clark
Rick Higbee
Pat Kreher
Elyce Mouskondis
Joan Nichol
Dee Rowland
David Sonnenreich
Debra Stone
Erin Trenbeath
Members Absent:
Sen. Robert Muhlestein
Rep. Margaret Dayton
Rep. David Jones
Rod Betit
Jill Rubadiri
Staff Present:
Mr. Mark Andrews
Research Analyst
Mr. James L. Wilson,
Associate General Counsel
Ms. Wendy L. Bangerter,
Legislative Secretary
Note: A list of others present and a copy of materials distributed in the meeting are on file in the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel.
1. Call to Order - Chair Blackham called the meeting to order at 9:40 a.m.
MOTION: Sen. Suazo moved to approve the minutes of July 1, 1998. The motion passed unanimously.
2. Child Care Funding
Ms. Barbara Gitten, Budget Director, Department of Workforce Services, explained the state's funding for child care. She also explained the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) grant, which is a 6-yr block grant. Once the TANF grant has satisfied the family employment and assistance programs for which it was designed, remaining funds, up to 20 percent, can be used for child care. As Family Employment Program cases drop and the state spends less than the full amount of its TANF grant, the money is placed in a rainy day fund. Figures for that fund will be available in a few months. DWS plans to have a 6-year revenue and spending projection prepared for the Legislature to review during the 1999 General Session.
She also explained the federal funding available for child care and indicated that the state's General Funds needed to fully match those child care dollars and those matching funds cannot come from federal monies. She distributed a graph to the task force members that indicated how much the state would need in matching dollars to maximize the receipt of federal funds.
Ms. Helen Thatcher, Assistant Director, Employment Development Division, Department of Workforce Services, explained that the family income eligibility ceiling for state assistance is 62% of state median income and that reimbursement to consumers for child care is based on a
sliding income scale. She explained the cap amount the state will pay and how parents can increase their amount of subsidy, if needed. The rate is driven by what providers charge and the
subsidies often do not satisfy those charges. At this time, parents are not being required to
choose licensed providers. She stated that by October, DWS plans to reimburse consumers who
use accredited child care centers at a rate higher than the rate provided to consumers who use
non-accredited centers.
Rep. Allen requested that the Department of Workforce Services supply the task force
with a simplified version of the restrictions on the use of TANF funds for child care. She asked
that DWS report at the September 22, 1998 meeting of the task force.
Ms. Elyce Mouskondis cautioned the task force about using TANF funds. She stated that
the state should not become too dependent on federal money. TANF funds could be used as
bonus dollars.
3. Coordination of Training
Ms. Julie Baker, State office of Education, reviewed Governor Leavitt's initiative for
literacy in Utah and emphasized the need to go forward so issues do not get worse. The two
initiatives the governor has endorsed are:
.
A campaign to get parents to read to their children.
.
To reach at least 12,000 at-risk youth and improve their reading by the year 2000.
She stated that every family needs to know what a learning environment is like and that
includes quality child care. She recommended that a training vehicle be created for all adults that
work with children.
Trainers would be trained at universities and then they will train others.
Trainers will be used by three different facilitators: the child care provider and parent, Head
Start, and the local PTA and Elementary schools.
Sen. Blackham suggested that all students who anticipate becoming parents be required to
take child care classes.
4. Criminal Background Checks
Mr. Jim Wilson explained the draft legislation titled "Child Care Provider Criminal
Background Check Amendments." He reviewed the requirements for FBI fingerprint and
national checks and who pays for it. The proposal provides that subsequent national records
checks would be unnecessary if a child care provider remained in the state.
MOTION: Elyce Mouskondis moved to recommend the draft legislation be approved as a committee bill.
Mr. Sonnenreich expressed concern that it is too easy for a person who wishes to do ill to
children to become licensed as a day-care provider and that the current draft would allow a
person to leave the state for three years, become convicted of an offense and even serve time in
prison, then come back to Utah and avoid a background check.
SUBSTITUTE MOTION: David Sonnenreich moved to amend the draft legislation to require an FBI background check for all persons submitting for initial licenses and for renewals
of persons who have been out of the state. The substitute motion passed with Sen. Blackham,
Rep. Allen and Elyce Mouskondis voting in opposition.
5. Regulation of Child Care
Ms. Debra Wynkoop-Green, director, bureau of licensing, Department of Health, and Doug Springmeyer, Department of Health, distributed and reviewed a matrix showing the four
categories of child care licenses. They reviewed changes made in the matrix that indicate the
differences in residential certificates, licensed family care, child care centers, and hourly-rate
child care centers. They reviewed the inspection program and stated that inspectors are quality
checked for consistency throughout the system.
Ms. Iona Thraen, director, Health Systems Improvement, Department of Health,
suggested there be a mechanism to reward certificate providers for going beyond what is
required, which would act as an incentive for them to continue to improve the quality of child
care. She stated that she is forming a subcommittee to study that issue.
6. Other Business
Sen. Blackham distributed a list of potential objectives and study issues to the task force.
He asked them to prioritize them and return them to staff. A discussion of the results will be on
the agenda for the next task force meeting.
Ms. Pat Kreher distributed a summary of the weaknesses and recommendations for child
care services identified at the first meeting. She also distributed information regarding the child
care challenges in Utah from the Children's Defense Fund.
Ms. Dee Rowland was introduced as the newest member of the task force. Ms. Rowland is a representative of the religious community.
7. Adjourn
MOTION: At 12:00 noon, David Sonnenreich moved to adjourn the meeting. The
motion passed unanimously.
[Back to the Interim Directory][Back to the Monthly Schedule][Back to the Committee Listing] Utah State Legislature