Juvenile Justice Task Force

findings to the Health and Human Services Interim Committee. He wondered if there is a better audience to hear this report. Ms. Robin Williams said she would make contact with this task force.

    Ms. Rachel Fischer, Utah Children, distributed a handout "Gaps and Solutions in Juvenile Justice Intermediate/Alternative Sanctions." She identified six gaps in intermediate sanctions: 1) Inadequate specialized programs in the Division of Child and Family Services (DCFS) to effectively deal with juvenile offenders who are referred to DCFS programs; 2) Inadequate programming to differentiate between genders; 3) Few programs in youth corrections which specialize in minority issues; 4) Improvement needed in the amount of vocational programs offered and in the consistency of credit provided for educational programs; 5) Juvenile delinquents committing many different types of crimes for many reasons, with many programs operating under the assumption that delinquency has a singular common cause; and 6) Generic outcome measures, rather than problem-specific measurement.

    Judge Mark J. Andrus, Second District Juvenile Court, identified from an urban perspective some of the needs regarding intermediate sanctions: 1) Secure confinement for children under the age of 12 who are violent offenders; 2) An intermediate sanction that deals with truancy; 3) More work camp programs; and 4) A holding facility for residential sexual offenders who are not progressing in the program because of mental retardation or other problems.

    Judge Scott N. Johansen, Seventh District Juvenile Court, suggested six areas of focus regarding intermediate/alternative sanctions: 1) Continue to research and gather data to determine outcome measurements of state supervision and its success; 2) Require an accounting of the sentencing guideline money; 3) Address truancy and educational neglect issues; 4) Appropriate more funding for restitution programs; 5) Require parents to pay for restitution; 6) Stop sending youth back home to a toxic environment; give DYC access to DCFS parenting classes; and 7) Re-evaluate secure care with its high costs and low success rate. He suggested teaching basic competency skills such as cutting hair, carpentry, or welding.

    Mr. William Dinehart, Legislative Fiscal Analyst, said over the last ten years the biggest problem in developing new facilities is the focus on cost per bed. He said if the task force believes there should be an increase of vocational space, it should communicate this to the Capitol Facilities Committee.

    Mr. Dalton explained that DYC is in the process of looking at a vocational plan that would offer employers incentives to employ youth and keep them working. He reported that statistically a youth needs to be engaged in a job for six weeks in order to ensure they will stay at the job.

4.    Serious Habitual Offender Comprehensive Action Program (SHOCAP)

    Chief Doyle Talbot, Layton City Police Department, distributed a handout "SHOCAP Davis County" and Mr. Alan Pratt, Davis County Sheriff's Office, Davis County SHOCAP Officer, made the presentation. Chief Talbot said the program has been successful and he has invited others in the state to become involved with SHOCAP.

    Mr. Pratt reviewed the handout and presented an overview of SHOCAP which is an interagency case management system that enables the juvenile justice system, schools, and human services agencies to make informed decisions about the small number of juveniles who repeatedly commit serious crimes. He discussed the three goals of the SHOCAP program: 1) Identify serious habitual offenders in the community; 2) Provide interagency services to meet the variety of needs these juveniles have thereby reducing recidivism; and 3) Enhance the collaborative supervision of SHOCAP to provide for and improve community safety and security.

    Chief Talbot recommended to the task force that if this program is going to be implemented statewide, there needs to be a SHOCAP coordinator at the state level.

    Sen. Tanner recognized the need for an appropriation to implement this program in the metro counties in the next two years.

    Rep. Chard recognized not only the need for a coordinator but also the need for a trainer to help the other agencies put the agreements together. He would like to see the task force continue to endorse this concept.

    Sen. Hull spoke in support of the concept of having a state coordinator/facilitator so that there is some description to establish a budget for appropriation.

    Chair Hillyard asked Ms. Anthony to follow up on these recommendations and report to the task force next month.

    Mr. Pratt suggested formalizing the interagency agreement throughout the state.

5.    Use of Out-of-State Resources

    Mr. Gary K. Dalton, Director, Division of Youth Corrections, referred to the handout distributed earlier from DYC on the "Actual and expected numbers of youth in out-of-state placements." He reviewed the chart of out-of-state agencies for alternatives to secure care. He reported that there are 42 youth in out-of-state placements as of May 29, 1998. He indicated he

would like to request an additional $500,000 for another 13-14 out-of-state beds in next year's budget.

6.    Interstate Compact

    Ms. Kristine Prince, Administrative Office of the Courts, distributed a handout "Interstate Compact on Juveniles" and presented an overview. She said the Interstate Compact on Juveniles was adopted to serve the ends of justice, protect the welfare and safety of the juvenile, and to protect the community. The basic purpose of the compact is to assist in the return of runaways, escapees, and absconders, and to provide cooperative supervision of probationers and parolees. She expressed concern that Utah receives more youth from out-of-state than it sends out. She reported that Utah is supervising 135 juveniles from out-of-state.

    Mr. Gary K. Dalton, Director, Division of Youth Corrections, discussed the problems with the Interstate Compact and recommended coordinating a response for the state. He also suggested administering the compact in one office.

7.    Adjournment

    MOTION: At 4:15 p.m., Rep. Haymond moved to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed unanimously.