Members Present:
Sen. L. Steven Poulton, Senate Chair
Rep. Peter C. Knudson, House Chair
Sen. David L. Buhler
Sen. Michael G. Waddoups
Rep. Gerry A. Adair
Rep. Eli H. Anderson
Rep. Patrice M. Arent
Rep. Afton B. Bradshaw
Rep. Katherine M. Bryson
Rep. Don E. Bush
Rep. Wayne A. Harper
Rep. Brad King
Rep. Loraine T. Pace
Rep. Glenn L. Way
Rep. David L. Zolman, Sr.
Members Excused:
Sen. Eddie "Ed" P. Mayne
Rep. Bradley T. Johnson
Members Absent:
Rep. Steve Barth
Staff Present:
Ms. Mary Catherine Perry,
Research Analyst
Ms. Patricia Owen,
Associate General Counsel
Ms. Beverlee LeCheminant,
Legislative Secretary
Note: Names of others present and copies of information distributed at the meeting are on file in the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel.
1. Call to Order - Chair Poulton called the meeting to order at 2:30 p.m.
2. Committee Business -
MOTION: Rep. Adair moved to approve the minutes of the August 19, 1998 meeting. The motion passed unanimously with Rep. Anderson, Rep. Harper, Rep. King, and Rep. Zolman absent for the vote.
Ms. Mary Catherine Perry, Research Analyst, asked that committee members who are interested in reviewing memos from selected agencies scheduled to sunset this year contact her for copies.
3. Renter Impact Fees - Sen. Steven Poulton said that there is some concern among apartment complex owners that cities are assessing unfair impact fees on apartment owners. He indicated that cities say it is because apartment complexes require more services.
Mr. Greg Fredde, Vice President, Taxpayers Association, said that in 1997 the Legislature changed cities imposition of business license fees and required cities to prepare a report which calculates and outlines their impact fee schedules. Mr. Fredde indicated that reports reviewed by the Taxpayers Association are flawed in charging and determining business license fees relating to apartments and, consequently, apartment owners throughout Utah are facing huge business license
fees that cannot be justified. He suggested that an analysis to justify business license fees,
particularly on apartments, needs to be done on a per unit basis and should be reviewed periodically
to ensure that the level of license fee adequately supports the service demand.
Mr. Kevin Howe, Senior Manager, Archstone Communities, briefed the committee on some
of the issues apartment complex owners are facing and how they are trying to address them.
Mr. Keith Nielson, Owner, Valley Park Apartments, said that Lieutenant Governor Olene
Walker, in her address at the Utah Apartment Association's trade show on the issue of affordable
housing, said that increased building costs of apartments is due in part to the large impact fees
assessed on apartment owners.
Mr. Bruce Wasden, Taylorsville City Councilman, indicated that some of the impact fees are
high but are needed to meet the additional need created by the impact of people in a small area. He
encouraged the committee to look at the demands for services that are made on cities by the high
impact by apartment dwellers.
Sen. Poulton pointed out that if any of the presenters would like legislation drafted on this issue
to contact the members of the committee.
4. Impacts of Road Construction on Businesses - Ms. Mary Evans, Owner, Central Office Supply, explained to the committee the hardships businesses are going through with road
construction. She indicated that she hopes the Legislature will plan better in the future and offer
some relief to affected businesses such as discounts on sales tax or other tax incentives.
Ms. Karen Silver, Salt Lake Community Action Program, requested that the Legislature look
into the impact that road construction has on businesses and ask that better planning can be done in
the future.
5. Utah Technology Finance Corporation (UTFC) Task Force Report - Mr. David Simmons, Task Force Chair, said that he chairs a task force to review the operations of UTFC and he indicated
that the task force has not completed its work, but hopes to do so within the next month. He stated
that the task force has been looking at UTFC's original purpose and whether or not there is a
continued need for its services. He indicated that the task force is close to finalizing
recommendations and those recommendations will be given to the Department of Community and
Economic Development board at its November board meeting. Mr. Simmons said that a copy of
those recommendations will also be submitted to the committee for its review. He stated that the
task force is in large part in support of UTFC.
6. Consolidation of Economic Development Functions - Ms. Mary Catherine Perry, Research Analyst, gave a brief background of business recruiting in Utah, as performed by the Economic
Development Corporation of Utah (EDCU) and the Division of Business and Economic
Development within the Department of Community and Economic Development (DCED). She
provided committee members with a printed copy of her presentation.
Mr. Rick Mayfield, Director, Division of Business and Economic Development, said that
DCED has identified overlap with EDCU in the area of business recruiting and a task force was
formed to study this issue.
Mr. Lou Callister, Chair, EDCU, indicated that the task force's recommendation was to
combine the Economic Development Corporation of Utah and the national recruiting staff of the
Division of Business and Economic Development into a new organization to be named the Utah
Business Development Partnership, which would be chaired by the governor. Mr. Callister
explained that the expected benefits of this merger would be: 1) elimination of duplicated efforts;
2) a combined organization that has more capabilities, including the ability to employ industry
specialists and rural specialists; and 3) the opportunity to build a world class organization that could
benefit from opportunities presented by the Olympic Winter Games.
Mr. Mayfield said that the challenge of the governor was to make sure that there was local
consensus for merging the two organizations together. When the first task force published its
recommendations, some of the local economic development professionals had concerns with the
proposal and a second task force was created. Mr. Mayfield indicated that the recommendations
of the second task force were: 1) that the new organization have a policy advisory board made up
of local economic development professionals; 2) that the executive committee be represented by the
entire state and not just Salt Lake City; 3) that the partnership have other functions in addition to
business recruiting; 4) that the new organization honor commitments to rural Utah; and 5) that a
training program be set up for local economic developers. Mr. Mayfield told the committee that the
department has met with the cochairs of the task force and will meet with the entire task force on
Friday, October 30th to make sure that the members are in consensus with the recommendations. After that meeting, the intent of the department is to receive the governor's approval and then move
ahead with merging the two organizations.
Mr. Larry Bunkall, President, Utah Manufacturers Association (UMA), said that UMA has no
position on this issue, but asked if there is a problem legally with the concept of state departments
awarding contracts to a single organization and not offering them to whoever would like to bid on
them.
Mr. Callister explained that the legal side is being looked at by an attorney with the state to
make sure that the merger is done in accordance with law and regulation and the department would
welcome the committee's involvement in this process.
Rep. Adair suggested that the committee staff follow up on the issue of state contracting.
7. Licensing of Talent Agencies - Ms. Patricia Owen, Associate General Counsel, said that during the 1998 General Session Senator Mayne sponsored S.B. 193, which would have created a
licensing classification for talent agents. She indicated that because the bill was drafted late in the
session and time did not permit full discussion of it, Sen. Mayne requested that the bill be brought
before the committee for further discussion.
Ms. Leigh Vonderesch, Director, Film Commission, DCED, spoke in opposition to the
legislation as it is now written and would be willing to work on fine tuning the legislation to the
benefit of the industry in the state.
Mr. Randall Edwards, an attorney with Christensen and Jensen, representing the TMG Talent
Agency, spoke in opposition of the bill.
Mr. Jerry Hoockey, Business Representative for the Screen Actors Guild, spoke in favor of the
bill.
Ms. Linda Bearman, Talent Management Group, spoke in opposition of the bill.
Ms. Diane Woodhouse spoke in favor of the bill.
Mr. Lance Williams, President of America International Media, spoke in opposition of the bill.
Ms. Susie McCarty, McCarty Agency, spoke in opposition of the bill.
Mr. Scott Shurian, Talent Manager Group, spoke in opposition of the bill.
8. Adjourn -
MOTION: Rep. Pace moved to adjourn the meeting. The motion passed unanimously with Sen. Waddoups, Rep. Arent, Rep. Knudson, Rep. King, and Rep. Harper were absent for the vote.
Chair Poulton adjourned the meeting at 5:00 p.m.
[Back to the Interim Directory][Back to the Monthly Schedule][Back to the Committee Listing] Utah State Legislature