From: Water News
To: boydclayton,
Subject: SLC caused $500,000 be wasted over $110.32 in water "impairment" at SLC rates or $34 at Orem rates
Date: Tue Sep 02 22:22:02 MDT 2014
Body:
The Water Problem: There is a bug in Utah's water laws where  the vagueness or vagaries of impairment claims are used by water protestants to clog the water transfer process, extend the transfer process for a decade, and clog the district courts.

Water rights are being gamed and used as land planning tools against private property owners.


The Procedural Solution: Require water protestant to water transfer to quantify in gallons and dollars their claimed impairment and against a specific water right.

If the gallon and dollar amount of water right impairment is required in protests, then meritless protests will be greatly reduced.  The State will save money and have a more efficient water transfer process


Example, If SLC was required 10 years ago to put into gallons and dollars it so-called impairment like "Salt Lake City Water Right 57-9046 will be impaired in the amount of $110.32 dollars."  Had this been required by the State Engineer, then no 6 hour hearing or 10 years process would have occurred.

How could a City Council justify spending $200,000 over a $110.32 impairment to prevent a build permit while allowing 3,650 water connections in the same canyon.  

No District Judge would take a $110.32 water impairment claim appeal seriously.  

The tiny impairment claimed by protestants are an indicator that Utah needs Nevada's water policies of allowing tiny amounts of domestic water without a permit for all private property including Trust Lands for education.

The State Engineer, State District Judges does not have the time, money, or energy to waste on a $110.32 water impairment claim easily resolved by a one page mitigation agreement.

Further, it should be a law that if the impairment is less than small claims court limit of $5,000 ($2,500 less than the $7,500 Small Claim limit), then State Engineer's decision should be unappealable to court.  Small claim damage are not allowed in District Court nor should  impairment claims of less than 5,000.  Mitigation contracts could be required, but using the AG's Office to defend a State Engineer's  Memo on a $110.32 impairment claim is a waste of time, money and energy.

What is the point of granting a $100.32 water impairments full access to District Courts, the Appeals Court and Utah Supreme Court?  Court resources are stretched too thin now.

Currently the law allows for monetary mitigation to impairment.  If the impairment is quantified in gallons and dollars, the water transfer process would be accelerated. 

SLC has tried to slip language into water bills to remove the monetary mitigation option to re-establish absolute control over land development by monopolizing water.  If SLC is successful, then SLC will be able to dictate land development in 128,000 acres outside SLC corporate boundaries. 

It appears the State Engineer was unduly pressured by SLC to hold a 6 hour water hearing over a maximum potential $110.32 water impairment to a SLC water claim in a source where 50% of the water runs to waste.

There was more money in the Soda vending machine in the lobby of the Division of Water Rights than in dispute  in the Division's largest conference room.

The math to get to $100.32 is straightforward.  A house in Alta uses $205 gallons of water.  The lot has 50 gallons a day from a water share.  The lot is short 155 gallons of water per day.

155 gallons x 365 = 56,575 gallons  The SLC surplus County rate is $1.95 per 1,000 gallons.  The max potential impairment possible would be $110.32.

In Orem, the cost would be substantially less or about $34.00  

Side Note: How does Orem sell water for about $0.60 per 1,000 gallons where SLC sells water to "surplus" County customers for $4.21 per 1,000 gallons?

Mr. Tolton even purchased a separate water right in Little Cottonwood Creek.  SLC insisted Sandy sue Mr. Tolton.  Sandy sued and lost.  Sandy appealed to the Supreme Court and lost.  The State Engineer finally approved Mr. Tolton's water transfer after a 10 year process.  SLC and associates again sued Mr. Tolton.

Over $500,000 has been wasted in this fight for a cabin in Cecret Lake where 7 other cabins exist and 3,650 other water connections granted by SLC.  While I'm opposed to building in the canyons as well as in Salt Lake Valley due to its depleted airshed, it's simply disingenuous for public employees to use public funds to break federal, state, county, and city laws of taking property for a public purpose without paying just compensation.

Who would spend $32,000 on water engineering studies over $100.32 3 water impairment? 

In addition to requiring impairment in gallons and dollars, the Legislature should consider adopt a few of Nevada's good water policies to cut water paperwork on minimal amounts of depletable water.  A reasonable person would not hold a 6 hour hearing or allow a water transfer process to go on for 10 years over 8.65 gallons of depletable water per day.  Most likely the cabin would be used 60 days, so 519 gallons of depletable water in a year.

If Utah had Nevada's water policy on minimal domestic water on private property, there would be a lot more education tax dollars in Utah's coffers.

SLC granted 3,000 water connections to Snowbird, and 650 water connections to Alta.  Alta uses about 60, but SLC told Alta Mr. Tolton could not connect to the towns water line abutting his land.

  
Background:

Mr. Tolton's father was the Town of Alta's Attorney who purchased two buildable lot in Alta's Cecret Lake Subdivion.  The lots were acquired by Mr. Tolton.

What Mr. Tolton did not realize is that Salt Lake City had targeted his lots for public use.  SLC hatched and carried out an elaborate scheme to dispute road access, closed the water company supplying water to his lots, and have the County re-write the septic tank codes to place artificial regulatory barriers to obtaining a building permit.   

What happened to Mr. Tolton in the process of obtaining water for his cabin could not legally happen in any other state not even in the driest State of Nevada.

While we all recognize it is against federal, state, county, and city laws and ordinances to take private property without paying just compensation, Utah's water laws have been changed over the past 25 years to enable the taking of private property for a public recreational purpose without paying just compensation using water rights.

Shouldn't we put into Utah's water policies and practices procedures to prevent the taking of private property without paying just compensation using water rights?

Who was there to protect an ailing 80 year old Richard Howe who finally gave up and sold his ski-in ski out lot in Alta for $35,000, because his access to water was cut by SLC which closed the water company supplying him water.


Utahwaternews801


Below is the public record of the scanned doc file for water right 57-7800 owned by Mr. Tolton. 


This is a public record - Think about $110.32 as you listen to the recording of the water hearing on Tolton's water transfer.  As you scroll through the 343 entries processed by the State Engineer think of $100.32. 

Link to 57-7800 on Division of Water Rights - 



        1      03/27/2014  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   On Petition to Stay OSE, 4 pages(file 57-7800-9)
        2      03/21/2014  Cover                                    Cover pg for Maack Opposition to petition to stay
        3      03/21/2014  Hearing Documents                        Response to S L C Stay Request -(file 57-7800-9)
        4      03/20/2014  Legal                                    Opposition to petition to stay(file 57-7800-8)
        5      03/14/2014  Correspondence                           Town of Alta Supporting Petition to Stay, a28548
        6      03/11/2014  Correspondence                           Alta Ski Area - Letter of Support Petition to Stay
        7      03/07/2014  Correspondence                           Metropolitan Water Dist SL&Sandy supports petition
        8      02/27/2014  Correspondence (from Division)           a28548, 3 pages
        9      02/26/2014  ACTIVE LITIGATION NOTICE  (pink sheet)   a28548
       10      02/24/2014  Legal                                    SLC Corp Petition to Stay, 13 pages
       11      02/24/2014  Exhibit B                                MAP
       12      02/19/2014  Legal                                    Summons, 65 pages
       13      01/09/2014  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   a28548, Change Approved/12 pages
       14      09/23/2013  Segregation History (green sheet)        4 pgs.
       15      06/14/2013  Address Change Request                   
       16      06/06/2013  Address Change Notice                    a28548
       17      05/31/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec
       18      05/31/2013  Envelope                                 
       19      05/28/2013  Correspondence                           Cottonwood Hydro LLC clarification ltr dated 5/22
       20      05/22/2013  Correspondence                           Cottonwood Hydro, LLC predecessor of Alta Energy
       21      04/25/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec
       22      04/22/2013  Correspondence                           SLC resp to Mr Jensen 3/29 & Dr Tolton 4/1-/27pgs
       23      04/04/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec
       24      04/04/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec
       25      04/01/2013  Correspondence                           Daniel A. Jensen to letter dated 2/28/13/80 pgs
       26      04/01/2013  Correspondence                           Kevin Tolton to letter dated 2/28/13/654 pgs
       27      03/14/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of supplemental documents received (a28548)
       28      03/12/2013  Protest                                  a28548, SLC Resp to St. Eng. Ltr 02/28/ 2013/23 pg
       29      03/06/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec
       30      03/05/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Protest Withdrawal
       31      03/04/2013  Protest                                  Supplemental Docs - by MWDSLS
       32      02/28/2013  Envelope                                 returned mail
       33      02/28/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Req for Recon  --1/23/13 Clarification/18 pgs
       34      02/28/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Specific Ref is made to Mr Martin/4 pgs
       35      02/28/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Clarification of divided historic uses - 6 pgs
       36      02/28/2013  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   Extension a24463 - 3 pages
       37      02/27/2013  Protest Withdrawl                        by Alta Energy LLC
       38      02/27/2013  Address Change Request                   Sandy City/2 pgs
       39      02/27/2013  Test Well                                1357002M00 - 16 pages
       40      02/22/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec/7 pgs
       41      02/22/2013  Envelope                                 returned mail (Friends of Alta c/o Patrick Shea)
       42      02/22/2013  Envelope                                 returned mail (Alta Ski Lifts Co c/o Jeffery Appel
       43      02/20/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec
       44      02/15/2013  Correspondence                           by Salt Lake City Corp & Metropolitan Water/6 pgs
       45      02/13/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Informal Dis.  at my office on Feb. 6, 2013/5 pgs
       46      02/13/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Docs Rec/2 pgs
       47      02/11/2013  Correspondence                           by Daniel A. Jensen, Attorney for Applicants/2 pgs
       48      02/04/2013  Address Change Request                   by Friends of Alta
       49      01/30/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Req. of Rec GRANTED a28548/2 pgs
       50      01/28/2013  Request for Reconsideration              by Sandy City - Mailed Copy
       51      01/24/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Req of Recon Rec/2 pgs
       52      01/24/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Req of Recon Rec/2 pgs
       53      01/24/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Req of Recon Rec/2 pgs
       54      01/24/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Req of Recon Rec/2 pgs
       55      01/24/2013  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Req of Recon Rec/2 pgs
       56      01/24/2013  Address Change Request                   for Alta Ski Lifts Co.
       57      01/24/2013  Envelope                                 
       58      01/23/2013  Request for Reconsideration              by Salt Lake City Corp./37 pages
       59      01/23/2013  Request for Reconsideration              by Alta Ski Lifts Company
       60      01/23/2013  Request for Reconsideration              by Sandy City
       61      01/23/2013  Request for Reconsideration              by Metropolitan Water District of S L & Sand/3 pgs
       62      01/23/2013  Request for Reconsideration              by Sandy Irrigation Co./3 pgs
       63      01/03/2013  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   12 pgs, a28548
       64      01/03/2013  Envelope                                 
       65      08/03/2012  Extension of time Request                a24463
       66      06/29/2012  Proof Due                                
       67      02/28/2012  E-Mail                                   
       68      02/28/2012  E-Mail                                   
       69      02/28/2012  E-Mail                                   
       70      02/28/2012  E-Mail                                   
       71      02/28/2012  E-Mail                                   
       72      02/23/2012  E-Mail                                   2 pages
       73      09/16/2011  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Documents Rec
       74      09/16/2011  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   3 pages
       75      09/15/2011  Protest                                  Supplemental Documents/4 pgs
       76      09/07/2011  Correspondence (from Division)           Notice of Supplemental Documents Rec
       77      09/01/2011  Protest                                  189 pages, Supplemental to Protest
       78      09/01/2011  Protest                                  Map, Supplemental to Protest
       79      07/28/2011  Maps                                     8 pages, a28548 & a28545
       80      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          MAP
       81      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
       82      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
       83      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (P) 70 pages
       84      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
       85      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
       86      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (I) 201 pages/look for this in hard copies. . .
       87      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (N) 147 pages
       88      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (O) 15 pages
       89      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          map
       90      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
       91      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (G) 69 pages
       92      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (J) 33 pages/look for this in hard copies. . .
       93      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          pages 6N and 56 N, pictures
       94      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (Q) 41 pages  (page 8Q does not exist)
       95      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (TT) 19 pages
       96      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (D) 6 pages
       97      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (S) 4 pages
       98      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (T) 2 pages
       99      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (U) 6 pages
      100      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (F) 8 pages
      101      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (K) 27 pages/look for this in hard copies. . .
      102      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (M) 118 pages
      103      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (C) 22 pages
      104      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (E) 18 pages
      105      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (H) 8 pages
      106      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (L) 18 pages/look for this in hard copies. . .
      107      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (B) 9 pages
      108      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (R) 5 pages
      109      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          2 pages
      110      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
      111      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          
      112      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          2 pages
      113      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          2 pages
      114      07/13/2011  Hearing Exhibit                          (A) 7 pages
      115      07/13/2011  Hearing Recording (sound byte)           57-7800 Kevin Tolton (Nonuse)
      116      07/13/2011  Map                                      
      117      07/13/2011  Hearing Recording (sound byte)           a28548 & a28545 Kevin Tolton & Judith Maack Part 2
      118      07/13/2011  Hearing Recording (sound byte)           a28548 & a28545 Kevin Tolton & Judith Maack Part 1
      119      07/13/2011  Hearing Notes (handwritten notes)        2 pages
      120      07/13/2011  Hearing Notes (handwritten notes)        11 pages
      121      06/13/2011  Hearing Notice                           REVISED/2 pgs
      122      06/13/2011  Envelope                                 
      123      06/09/2011  Envelope                                 
      124      06/09/2011  Envelope                                 
      125      06/09/2011  Envelope                                 
      126      06/09/2011  Envelope                                 
      127      06/09/2011  Hearing Notice                           2 pgs
      128      06/06/2011  Address Change Request                   
      129      08/27/2009  Notice of Protest                        Late Protest by Sandy City
      130      06/08/2009  Correspondence                           
      131      06/03/2009  Envelope                                 
      132      06/03/2009  Notice of Protest                        late
      133      06/03/2009  Notice of Protest                        late
      134      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           letter of concern
      135      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           page 2
      136      06/02/2009  Exhibit A                                
      137      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      138      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      139      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      140      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      141      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           letter of concern
      142      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           page 2
      143      06/02/2009  Exhibit A                                
      144      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      145      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      146      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      147      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      148      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      149      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      150      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      151      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      152      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      153      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      154      06/02/2009  Exhibit B                                
      155      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      156      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      157      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      158      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      159      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      160      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      161      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      162      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      163      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      164      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      165      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      166      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      167      06/02/2009  Exhibit B                                
      168      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      169      06/02/2009  Protest (LATE)                           
      170      05/14/2009  Proof of publication                     
      171      04/09/2009  Non-Use Application                      2 pages
      172      09/10/2007  Scanning History Sheet                   bje
      173      09/07/2007  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   a24463 Extension Granted
      174      09/07/2007  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   pg 2
      175      09/07/2007  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   pg 3
      176      08/14/2007  Extension of time Request                a28548
      177      07/05/2007  Address Change Request                   Dr. Kevin Tolton (a28548)
      178      06/30/2007  60 Day Proof Due Notice                  a28548
      179      04/13/2005  Scanning History Sheet                   ra/
      180      04/12/2005  Hearing Notice                           a28548, postponed
      181      04/12/2005  Hearing Notice                           pg 2
      182      04/12/2005  Correspondence                           Answer to Sandy City`s claim of ownership - pg 1
      183      04/12/2005  Correspondence                           pg 2
      184      04/12/2005  Correspondence                           page 3
      185      04/11/2005  Correspondence                           a28548, from applicant to postponed hearing
      186      04/08/2005  Hearing Notice                           a28548
      187      04/08/2005  Hearing Notice                           pg 2
      188      08/12/2004  Correspondence (from Division)           concerning roc
      189      04/08/2004  Correspondence                           concerning change applications
      190      04/08/2004  Correspondence                           pg 2
      191      02/24/2004  Notice of Protest                        a28548
      192      02/13/2004  Notice of Protest                        a28548
      193      02/12/2004  Protest                                  Bill Lennon, Alta Energy
      194      02/11/2004  Correspondence                           Re: Protest cover letter
      195      02/11/2004  Protest                                  Salt Lake County Service Area #3 - pg 1
      196      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      197      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      198      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      199      02/11/2004  Protest                                  Sandy Irrigation Co.
      200      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      201      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      202      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      203      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 4
      204      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 5
      205      02/11/2004  Protest                                  Sandy City, a28548 - pg 1
      206      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      207      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      208      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 4
      209      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 10
      210      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 11
      211      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 12
      212      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 13
      213      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 14
      214      02/11/2004  Protest                                  MWDSLS
      215      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 4
      216      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 5
      217      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 6
      218      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 7
      219      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 8
      220      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 9
      221      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 7
      222      02/11/2004  Protest                                  USFS Intermountain Region
      223      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      224      02/11/2004  Protest                                  Alta Ski Lifts Co.
      225      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      226      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      227      02/11/2004  Protest                                  Town of Alta - pg 1
      228      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      229      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      230      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 4
      231      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 5
      232      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 6
      233      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 4
      234      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 5
      235      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 6
      236      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 7
      237      02/11/2004  Protest                                  Friends for Alta - pg 1
      238      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      239      02/11/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      240      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 20
      241      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 21
      242      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 22
      243      02/10/2004  Notice of Protest                        a28548
      244      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 14
      245      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 15
      246      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 16
      247      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 17
      248      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 18
      249      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 19
      250      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 8
      251      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 9
      252      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 10
      253      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 11
      254      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 12
      255      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 13
      256      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      257      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 3
      258      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 4
      259      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 5
      260      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 6
      261      02/10/2004  Protest                                  pg 7
      262      02/10/2004  Protest                                  SLC
      263      02/10/2004  Protest                                  Bill Lennon, Alta Energy
      264      02/09/2004  Protest                                  LCCDC - pg 1
      265      02/09/2004  Protest                                  pg 2
      266      02/  /2004  Scanning History Sheet                   ra/
      267      01/28/2004  Proof of publication                     a28548
      268      01/  /2004  Scanning History Sheet                   ra/
      269        /  /2004  Miscellaneous                            Little Cottonwood Creek Meeting Attendee List
      270        /  /2004  Miscellaneous                            pg 2
      271        /  /2004  Miscellaneous                            Roll
      272      12/31/2003  Segregation History (green sheet)        
      273      12/31/2003  Ownership printout                       
      274      12/29/2003  Segregation History (green sheet)        
      275      12/23/2003  Ownership printout                       
      276      12/23/2003  Ownership printout                       
      277      12/17/2003  Change Application                       pg 5
      278      12/17/2003  Map Verification                         
      279      12/17/2003  Map                                      Hereafter
      280      12/17/2003  Map                                      Hereafter
      281      12/17/2003  Change Application                       a28548
      282      12/17/2003  Change Application                       pg 2
      283      12/17/2003  Change Application                       pg 3
      284      12/17/2003  Change Application                       pg 4
      285      12/12/2003  Quitclaim Deed                           
      286      12/12/2003  Quitclaim Deed                           pg 2
      287      12/12/2003  Quitclaim Deed                           
      288      12/12/2003  Water Deed                               
      289      12/12/2003  Receipt                                  
      290      12/12/2003  Receipt                                  
      291      12/12/2003  Correspondence                           Re: Report of Conveyance enclosed
      292      12/12/2003  Report of Conveyance                     Sec. A - Kevin Tolton et al
      293      12/  /2003  Scanning History Sheet                   ra/
      294      11/13/2003  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   a24463 Extension Granted - pg 1
      295      11/13/2003  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   pg 2
      296      11/  /2003  Scanning History Sheet                   ra/
      297      08/15/2003  Extension of time Request                Before 14 years
      298      08/15/2003  Extension of time Request                Before 14 years
      299      08/15/2003  Correspondence                           Re: Extension of time request enclosed
      300      08/  /2003  Scanning History Sheet                   ra/
      301      06/30/2003  60 Day Proof Due Notice                  a24463
      302      06/30/2003  Envelope                                 
      303      02/19/2002  Correspondence                           Re: Address change enclosed
      304      02/19/2002  Address Change Request                   Lynn Christensen Biddulph
      305      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 10
      306      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 11
      307      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 12
      308      12/07/2000  Legal                                    Restated Water Supply Agreement
      309      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 2
      310      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 3
      311      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 4
      312      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 5
      313      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 6
      314      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 7
      315      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 8
      316      12/07/2000  Legal                                    pg 9
      317      10/  /2000  Scanning History Sheet                   jEN/
      318      08/04/2000  Approval Letter                          a24463
      319      08/04/2000  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   a24463, pg 1, Approved
      320      08/04/2000  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   pg 2
      321      08/04/2000  Memorandum Decision/Order St. Engineer   pg 3
      322      08/  /2000  Scanning History Sheet                   Jacki/
      323      07/10/2000  Notice of Protest                        
      324      06/28/2000  Protest                                  Sandy City
      325      06/28/2000  Notice of Protest                        
      326      06/21/2000  Protest                                  SLC
      327      06/15/2000  Proof of publication                     
      328      05/08/2000  Endorsement Page                         pg 5, a24463
      329      05/08/2000  Change Application                       pg 2
      330      05/08/2000  Change Application                       a24463 Original - pg 1
      331      05/08/2000  Change Application                       pg 3
      332      05/08/2000  Change Application                       a22463 Computer printout - pg 1
      333      05/08/2000  Change Application                       pg 3
      334      05/08/2000  Change Application                       pg 2