From: Jared Carman
To: David Lifferth,
Subject: YES on HB81
Date: Fri Feb 07 00:56:34 MST 2014

Rep. Lifferth,


Please vote YES on HB81 and pass it out of committee Friday. HB81 protects parental rights by allowing any parent to participate in the review process for the new SAGE (Common Core) tests. The bill protects test integrity via non-disclosure. See details, below.


Thank you,

Jared Carman

Precinct Vice Chair and Utah State Delegate







HB81 solves these two problems:

1.       Currently, only 15 Utah parents are allowed to participate in the review process. This should be open to any parent who is willing to participate, and will sign a non-disclosure agreement.

2.       The current non-disclosure agreement is too broad: it currently prohibits parents from discussing test questions. While probably well-intended, it is an infringement of 1st amendment rights. This can be fixed by removing the word “discuss.”


Additional data points:

·         The contract with the vendor (AIR) called for test questions to be reviewed by at least 100 parents.

·         The 15 parents allowed to participate reviewed approximately 10,000 questions in just 5 days.

·         The 15 parents flagged 597 questions that they found objectionable.

·         In spite of their concerns, only a fraction of these objectionable questions were dropped or changed (43 dropped, 156 changed). None of the parents was told which objectionable test questions remain in the test, or what changes were made. This is a concern for parents in districts around the state.



·         Parents have the Constitutionally-protected right and duty to exercise primary control over the care, supervision, upbringing, and education of their children (Utah Code Section 62A-4a-201).

·         The state's role is secondary and supportive to the primary role of a parent” (Utah Code Section 62A-4a-201).