From: Charles Hoydu
To: Rebecca Lockhart, Brad Dee, Greg Hughes, Don Ipson, Melvin Brown, Brad Wilson, Dean Sanpei, Jennifer M. Seelig, Tim Cosgrove, rchouch, Joel Briscoe,
Subject: Vote in Favor of HB 112
Date: Fri Feb 21 20:54:12 MST 2014

Dear Representative,


I am a Respiratory Care Practitioner in Salt Lake City. I urge you to vote in favor of HB 112 which would assist with the regulation of the manufacture, marketing and distribution of electronic cigarettes.  The government said for years that regular tobacco use was “safe”.  In the January 2014 report from the US Surgeon General, his fifty year review of the impact on tobacco use on American’s health was staggering. Research cannot assure of that e-cigarette use is safe!

Based on UDOH and CDC data:

1.     Kids use of e-cigarettes in Utah has tripled from 2011 to 2013 (while rest of the country has only doubled)

2.     Despite having no legal access to e-cigarettes, Utah youth are three times more likely to report current use than adults.

3.     Nearly one-third of Utah youth who use e-cigarettes report that they never tried conventional cigarettes. 

4.     E-cigarettes are the preferred tobacco products for Utah kids.  In some areas, as many as 20% of children use e-cigarettes regularly.

5.     All the major cigarette companies are now in the e-cigarette business.


The earlier individuals start smoking, the earlier they are hooked on nicotine and who knows whatever other products are in e-cig “juice”.  The earlier they are hooked, the longer they smoke.  The longer they smoke, the more likely they are to be diagnosed with Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) which is the 3RD leading cause of death in America.  Did you know that 85-90% of COPD is caused by tobacco use?  COPD is preventable! 


Tobacco damage to individuals is not as quickly apparent as drinking. Individuals do not have slurred speech, impaired driving not do they stumble.  However, the impact of tobacco use on individuals is slow and insidious.  E-cigarettes ARE versions of tobacco use.  I’ve heard the arguments:


1)      It’s a far reach of government to pass a law such as this.

2)      We can’t keep citizens from harming themselves even if e-cigarettes are being touted as “safe”.

3)      The smoker only hurts himself.

4)      Utah may lose tax revenue (e-sales, etc…)


If #1 and #2 are true, then why do we have laws regarding:  seat belt use, car seats for children, speed limits, texting while driving and even food inspections?  The answer is that these laws DO protect individuals and build on the greater good of the population.


Smokers do NOT only hurt themselves.  The impact of second and third hand smoke are just beginning to come to light.  We are not fully aware of the impact of e-cigarette “vapors” might have on other individuals. I have willingly paid into Medicare and Medicaid for my whole career.  I will not enjoy the same coverage the generation before me has enjoyed.  US healthcare has been practicing reactionary, patient focused care in that we wait for individuals to become sick and THEN treat them.  An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure!  SB 12 will help us focus on health promotion and disease prevention for a more population-based care model. This will lives and billions of healthcare dollars.


I read that Utah spent approximately $104 million Medicaid dollars alone for tobacco related illnesses.  This makes the smaller tax revenue loss pale in comparison.


Tobacco companies know the facts and are marketing specifically to our youth and are telling adults e-cigs are “safe”!  There is no evidence that the use of “e-cigs” help an individual with tobacco cessation.


Please vote in favor of protecting Utah’s children by voting “yes” to HB112.




C. Jeffrey Hoydu, MBA, RRT

Director Respiratory Care Services

Primary Children’s Hospital

100 N. Mario Capecchi Drive

Salt Lake City, Utah 84113

801-662-2682 – office

801-419-7779 - cell