This document includes Senate Committee Amendments incorporated into the bill on Thu, Feb 2, 2017 at 10:56 AM by lpoole.



Chief Sponsor: R. Curt Webb

Senate Sponsor: Daniel W. Thatcher


8     Committee Note:
9          The Political Subdivisions Interim Committee recommended this bill.
10     General Description:
11          This bill modifies provisions of the Assessment Area Act.
12     Highlighted Provisions:
13          This bill:
14          ▸     clarifies the required contents of a notice of a proposed assessment area designation;
15          ▸     provides that a local entity that levies an assessment for economic promotion
16     activities shall assess each benefitted property; and
17          ▸     makes technical and conforming changes.
18     Money Appropriated in this Bill:
19          None
20     Other Special Clauses:
21          None
22     Utah Code Sections Affected:
23     AMENDS:
24          11-42-202, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Chapters 85 and 371
25          11-42-409, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 396

27     Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:

28          Section 1. Section 11-42-202 is amended to read:
29          11-42-202. Requirements applicable to a notice of a proposed assessment area
30     designation.
31          (1) Each notice required under Subsection 11-42-201(2)(a) shall:
32          (a) state that the local entity proposes to:
33          (i) designate one or more areas within the local entity's jurisdictional boundaries as an
34     assessment area;
35          (ii) provide an improvement to property within the proposed assessment area; and
36          (iii) finance some or all of the cost of improvements by an assessment on benefitted
37     property within the assessment area;
38          (b) describe the proposed assessment area by any reasonable method that allows an
39     owner of property in the proposed assessment area to determine that the owner's property is
40     within the proposed assessment area;
41          (c) describe, in a general and reasonably accurate way, the improvements to be
42     provided to the assessment area, including:
43          (i) the nature of the improvements; and
44          (ii) the location of the improvements, by reference to streets or portions or extensions
45     of streets or by any other means that the governing body chooses that reasonably describes the
46     general location of the improvements;
47          (d) state the estimated cost of the improvements as determined by a project engineer;
48          (e) for the version of notice mailed in accordance with Subsection (4)(b), state the
49     estimated total assessment specific to the benefitted property for which the notice is mailed;
50          (f) state that the local entity proposes to levy an assessment on benefitted property
51     within the assessment area to pay some or all of the cost of the improvements according to the
52     estimated benefits to the property from the improvements;
53          (g) if applicable, state that an unassessed benefitted government property will receive
54     improvements for which the cost will be allocated proportionately to the remaining benefitted
55     properties within the proposed assessment area and that a description of each unassessed
56     benefitted government property is available for public review at the location or website
57     described in Subsection (6);
58          (h) state the assessment method by which the governing body proposes to [levy the]

59     calculate the proposed assessment, including, if the local entity is a municipality or county,
60     whether the assessment will be collected:
61          (i) by directly billing a property owner; or
62          (ii) by inclusion on a property tax notice issued in accordance with Section 59-2-1317
63     and in compliance with Section 11-42-401;
64          (i) state:
65          (i) the date described in Section 11-42-203 and the location at which protests against
66     designation of the proposed assessment area or of the proposed improvements are required to
67     be filed;
68          (ii) the method by which the governing body will determine the number of protests
69     required to defeat the designation of the proposed assessment area or acquisition or
70     construction of the proposed improvements; and
71          (iii) in large, boldface, and conspicuous type that a property owner must protest the
72     designation of the assessment area in writing if the owner objects to the area designation or
73     being assessed for the proposed improvements, operation and maintenance costs, or economic
74     promotion activities;
75          (j) state the date, time, and place of the public hearing required in Section 11-42-204;
76          (k) if the governing body elects to create and fund a reserve fund under Section
77     11-42-702, include a description of:
78          (i) how the reserve fund will be funded and replenished; and
79          (ii) how remaining money in the reserve fund is to be disbursed upon full payment of
80     the bonds;
81          (l) if the governing body intends to designate a voluntary assessment area, include a
82     property owner consent form that:
83          (i) estimates the total assessment to be levied against the particular parcel of property;
84          (ii) describes any additional benefits that the governing body expects the assessed
85     property to receive from the improvements;
86          (iii) designates the date and time by which the fully executed consent form is required
87     to be submitted to the governing body; and
88          (iv) if the governing body intends to enforce an assessment lien on the property in
89     accordance with Subsection 11-42-502.1(2)(c):

90          (A) appoints a trustee that satisfies the requirements described in Section 57-1-21;
91          (B) gives the trustee the power of sale; and
92          (C) explains that if an assessment or an installment of an assessment is not paid when
93     due, the local entity may sell the property owner's property to satisfy the amount due plus
94     interest, penalties, and costs, in the manner described in Title 57, Chapter 1, Conveyances;
95          (m) if the local entity intends to levy an assessment to pay operation and maintenance
96     costs or for economic promotion activities, include:
97          (i) a description of the operation and maintenance costs or economic promotion
98     activities to be paid by assessments and the initial estimated annual assessment to be levied;
99          (ii) a description of how the estimated assessment will be determined;
100          (iii) a description of how and when the governing body will adjust the assessment to
101     reflect the costs of:
102          (A) in accordance with Section 11-42-406, current economic promotion activities; or
103          (B) current operation and maintenance costs;
104          (iv) a description of the method of assessment if different from the method of
105     assessment to be used for financing any improvement; and
106          (v) a statement of the maximum number of years over which the assessment will be
107     levied for:
108          (A) operation and maintenance costs; or
109          (B) economic promotion activities;
110          (n) if the governing body intends to divide the proposed assessment area into
111     classifications under Subsection 11-42-201(1)(b), include a description of the proposed
112     classifications;
113          (o) if applicable, state the portion and value of the improvement that will be increased
114     in size or capacity to serve property outside of the assessment area and how the increases will
115     be financed; and
116          (p) state whether the improvements will be financed with a bond and, if so, the
117     currently estimated interest rate and term of financing, subject to Subsection (2), for which the
118     benefitted properties within the assessment area may be obligated.
119          (2) The estimated interest rate and term of financing in Subsection (1)(p) may not be
120     interpreted as a limitation to the actual interest rate incurred or the actual term of financing as

121     subject to the market rate at the time of the issuance of the bond.
122          (3) A notice required under Subsection 11-42-201(2)(a) may contain other information
123     that the governing body considers to be appropriate, including:
124          (a) the amount or proportion of the cost of the improvement to be paid by the local
125     entity or from sources other than an assessment;
126          (b) the estimated total amount of each type of assessment for the various improvements
127     to be financed according to the method of assessment that the governing body chooses; and
128          (c) provisions for any improvements described in Subsection 11-42-102(26)(a)(ii).
129          (4) Each notice required under Subsection 11-42-201(2)(a) shall:
130          (a) (i) (A) be published in a newspaper of general circulation within the local entity's
131     jurisdictional boundaries, once a week for four consecutive weeks, with the last publication at
132     least five but not more than 20 days before the day of the hearing required in Section
133     11-42-204; or
134          (B) if there is no newspaper of general circulation within the local entity's jurisdictional
135     boundaries, be posted in at least three public places within the local entity's jurisdictional
136     boundaries at least 20 but not more than 35 days before the day of the hearing required in
137     Section 11-42-204; and
138          (ii) be published on the Utah Public Notice Website described in Section 63F-1-701 for
139     four weeks before the deadline for filing protests specified in the notice under Subsection
140     (1)(i); and
141          (b) be mailed, postage prepaid, within 10 days after the first publication or posting of
142     the notice under Subsection (4)(a) to each owner of property to be assessed within the proposed
143     assessment area at the property owner's mailing address.
144          (5) (a) The local entity may record the version of the notice that is published or posted
145     in accordance with Subsection (4)(a) with the office of the county recorder, by legal description
146     and tax identification number as identified in county records, against the property proposed to
147     be assessed.
148          (b) The notice recorded under Subsection (5)(a) expires and is no longer valid one year
149     after the day on which the local entity records the notice if the local entity has failed to adopt
150     the designation ordinance or resolution under Section 11-42-201 designating the assessment
151     area for which the notice was recorded.

152          (6) A local entity shall make available on the local entity's website, or, if no website is
153     available, at the local entity's place of business, the address and type of use of each unassessed
154     benefitted government property described in Subsection (1)(g).
155          (7) If a governing body fails to provide actual or constructive notice under this section,
156     the local entity may not assess a levy against a benefitted property omitted from the notice
157     unless:
158          (a) the property owner gives written consent;
159          (b) the property owner received notice under Subsection 11-42-401(2)(a)(iii) and did
160     not object to the levy of the assessment before the final hearing of the board of equalization; or
161          (c) the benefitted property is conveyed to a subsequent purchaser and, before the date
162     of conveyance, the requirements of Subsections 11-42-206(3)(a)(i) and (ii), or, if applicable,
163     Subsection 11-42-207(1)(d)(i) are met.
164          Section 2. Section 11-42-409 is amended to read:
165          11-42-409. Assessment requirements and prohibitions -- Economic promotion
166     activities assessment requirements and prohibitions -- Allocation for unassessed
167     benefitted government property.
168          (1) (a) Each local entity that levies an assessment under this chapter:
169          (i) except for an appropriate allocation for an unassessed benefitted government
170     property, may not assess a property for more than the amount that the property benefits by the
171     improvement, operation and maintenance, or economic promotion activities;
172          (ii) may levy an assessment only for the actual costs that are reasonable; and
173          (iii) shall levy an assessment on a benefitted property in an amount that reflects an
174     equitable portion, subject to Subsection (1)(b), of the benefit the property will receive from an
175     improvement, operation and maintenance, or economic promotion activities for which the
176     assessment is levied.
177          (b) The local entity, in accounting for a property's benefit or portion of a benefit
178     received from an improvement, operation and maintenance, or economic promotion activities,
179     shall consider:
180          (i) any benefit that can be directly identified with the property; and
181          (ii) the property's roughly equivalent portion of the benefit that is collectively shared by
182     all the assessed properties in the entire assessment area or classification.

183          (c) The validity of an otherwise valid assessment is not affected by the fact that the
184     benefit to the property from the improvement does not increase the fair market value of the
185     property.
186          (2) [The] Subject to Subsection (4) Ŝ→ [
(d)] ←Ŝ , the assessment method a governing body
186a     uses
187     to calculate an assessment may be according to frontage, area, taxable value, fair market value,
188     lot, parcel, number of connections, equivalent residential unit, or any combination of these
189     methods, or any other method as the governing body considers appropriate to comply with
190     Subsections (1)(a) and (b).
191          (3) A local entity that levies an assessment under this chapter for an improvement:
192          (a) shall:
193          (i) (A) levy the assessment on each block, lot, tract, or parcel of property that benefits
194     from the improvement; and
195          (B) to whatever depth, including full depth, on the parcel of property that the governing
196     body determines but that still complies with Subsections (1)(a) and (b);
197          (ii) make an allowance for each corner lot receiving the same improvement on both
198     sides so that the property is not assessed at the full rate on both sides; and
199          (iii) pay for any increase in size or capacity that serves property outside of the
200     assessment area with funds other than those levied by an assessment;
201          (b) may:
202          (i) use different methods for different improvements in an assessment area;
203          (ii) assess different amounts in different classifications, even when using the same
204     method, if acquisition or construction costs differ from classification to classification;
205          (iii) allocate a corner lot allowance under Subsection (3)(a)(ii) to all other benefitted
206     property within the assessment area by increasing the assessment levied against the other
207     assessed property in the same proportion as the improvement is assessed;
208          (iv) to comply with Subsection (1)(a), levy an assessment within classifications; and
209          (v) assess property to replace improvements that are approaching or have exceeded
210     their useful life or to increase the level of service of an existing improvement; and
211          (c) may not:
212          (i) consider the costs of the additional size or capacity of an improvement that will be
213     increased in size or capacity to serve property outside of the assessment area when calculating

214     an assessment or determining an assessment method; or
215          (ii) except for in a voluntary assessment area or as provided in Subsection (3)(b)(v),
216     assess a property for an improvement that would duplicate or provide a reasonably similar
217     service that is already provided to the property.
218          (4) A local entity that levies an assessment under this chapter for economic promotion
219     activities:
220          (a) shall:
221          (i) Ŝ→ subject to Section 11-42-408, ←Ŝ levy the assessment on each benefitted property;
221a     and
222          (ii) subject to Subsection (4)(d), use an assessment method that, when applied to a
223     benefitted property, meets the requirements of Subsection (1)(a);
224          [(a)] (b) may:
225          (i) levy an assessment only on commercial or industrial real property; and
226          (ii) create classifications based on property use, or other distinguishing factors, to
227     determine the estimated benefit to the assessed property;
228          [(b)] (c) subject to Subsection (4)(d), may rely on, in addition to the assessment
229     methods described in Subsection (2), estimated benefits from an increase in:
230          (i) office lease rates;
231          (ii) retail sales rates;
232          (iii) customer base;
233          (iv) public perception;
234          (v) hotel room rates and occupancy levels;
235          (vi) property values;
236          (vii) the commercial environment from enhanced services;
237          (viii) another articulable method of estimating benefits; or
238          (ix) a combination of the methods described in Subsections (4)[(b)](c)(i) through (viii);
239     and
240          [(c) subject to Subsection (4)(d), shall use an assessment method that, when applied to
241     a benefitted property, meets the requirements of Subsection (1)(a); and]
242          (d) may not use taxable value, fair market value, or any other assessment method based
243     on the value of the property as the sole assessment method.
244          (5) A local entity may levy an assessment that would otherwise violate a provision of

245     this chapter if the owners of all property to be assessed voluntarily enter into a written
246     agreement with the local entity consenting to the assessment.
247          (6) A local entity may allocate the cost of a benefit received by an unassessed
248     benefitted government property to all other benefitted property within the assessment area by
249     increasing the assessment levied against the other assessed property in the same proportion as
250     the improvement, operation and maintenance, or economic promotion activities are assessed.

Legislative Review Note
Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel