Senator Scott D. Sandall proposes the following substitute bill:


1     
RURAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MODIFICATIONS

2     
2019 GENERAL SESSION

3     
STATE OF UTAH

4     
Chief Sponsor: Scott D. Sandall

5     
House Sponsor: Carl R. Albrecht

6     

7     LONG TITLE
8     General Description:
9          This bill modifies provisions related to economic development.
10     Highlighted Provisions:
11          This bill:
12          ▸     modifies enterprise zone provisions overseen by the Governor's Office of Economic
13     Development (GOED);
14          ▸     modifies provisions related to economic development tax increment financing;
15          ▸     repeals provisions related to certain GOED administered economic development
16     programs;
17          ▸     defines terms, including "rural county";
18          ▸     creates the Rural County Economic Development Grant Program (grant program);
19          ▸     describes the requirements and purposes of the grant program;
20          ▸     describes the requirements for a rural county to apply for a grant under the grant
21     program;
22          ▸     describes the requirements of GOED in administering the grant program; and
23          ▸     makes technical changes.
24     Money Appropriated in this Bill:
25          This bill appropriates in fiscal year 2020:

26          ▸     to the Governor's Office of Economic Development -- Rural County Economic
27     Development Grant Program, as an ongoing appropriation:
28               •     from the General Fund, $8,000,000; and
29          ▸     to the Governor's Office of Economic Development -- Rural County Economic
30     Development Grant Program, as a one-time appropriation:
31               •     from the General Fund, One-time, ($6,000,000).
32     Other Special Clauses:
33          This bill provides retrospective operation.
34     Utah Code Sections Affected:
35     AMENDS:
36          59-7-610, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
37          59-7-614.10, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Third Special Session, Chapter 1
38          59-10-210, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
39          59-10-1007, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
40          59-10-1037, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Third Special Session, Chapter 1
41          63C-10-103, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2018, Chapter 204
42          63N-2-103, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Chapter 350
43          63N-2-203, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 252
44          63N-2-204, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Chapter 11
45          63N-2-208, as renumbered and amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
46          63N-2-213, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2016, Third Special Session, Chapter 1
47          63N-2-403, as renumbered and amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
48          63N-2-705, as renumbered and amended by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
49     ENACTS:
50          63N-4-501, Utah Code Annotated 1953
51          63N-4-502, Utah Code Annotated 1953
52          63N-4-503, Utah Code Annotated 1953
53          63N-4-504, Utah Code Annotated 1953
54          63N-4-505, Utah Code Annotated 1953
55          63N-4-506, Utah Code Annotated 1953
56     REPEALS:

57          59-7-614.11, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 252
58          59-10-1039, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 252
59          63N-2-213.5, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 252
60          63N-2-301, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2015, Chapter 283
61          63N-2-302, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 352
62          63N-2-303, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 352
63          63N-2-304, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 352
64          63N-2-305, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2017, Chapter 352
65          63N-3-104, as last amended by Laws of Utah 2018, Chapter 204
66          63N-3-104.5, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2018, Chapter 204
67     

68     Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
69          Section 1. Section 59-7-610 is amended to read:
70          59-7-610. Recycling market development zones tax credit.
71          (1) For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 1996, a business operating in a
72     recycling market development zone as defined in Section 63N-2-402 may claim a tax credit as
73     provided in this section.
74          (a) (i) There shall be allowed a nonrefundable tax credit of 5% of the purchase price
75     paid for machinery and equipment used directly in:
76          (A) commercial composting; or
77          (B) manufacturing facilities or plant units that:
78          (I) manufacture, process, compound, or produce recycled items of tangible personal
79     property for sale; or
80          (II) reduce or reuse postconsumer waste material.
81          (ii) The Governor's Office of Economic Development shall certify that the machinery
82     and equipment described in Subsection (1)(a)(i) are integral to the composting or recycling
83     process:
84          (A) on a form provided by the commission; and
85          (B) before a taxpayer is allowed a tax credit under this section.
86          (iii) The Governor's Office of Economic Development shall provide a taxpayer seeking
87     to claim a tax credit under this section with a copy of the form described in Subsection

88     (1)(a)(ii).
89          (iv) The taxpayer described in Subsection (1)(a)(iii) shall retain a copy of the form
90     received under Subsection (1)(a)(iii).
91          (b) There shall be allowed a nonrefundable tax credit equal to 20% of net expenditures
92     up to $10,000 to third parties for rent, wages, supplies, tools, test inventory, and utilities made
93     by the taxpayer for establishing and operating recycling or composting technology in Utah,
94     with an annual maximum tax credit of $2,000.
95          (2) The total nonrefundable tax credit allowed under this section may not exceed 40%
96     of the Utah income tax liability of the taxpayer prior to any tax credits in the taxable year of
97     purchase prior to claiming the tax credit authorized by this section.
98          (3) (a) Any tax credit not used for the taxable year in which the purchase price on
99     composting or recycling machinery and equipment was paid may be carried over for credit
100     against the business' income taxes in the three succeeding taxable years until the total tax credit
101     amount is used.
102          (b) Tax credits not claimed by a business on the business' state income tax return
103     within three years are forfeited.
104          (4) The commission shall make rules governing what information shall be filed with
105     the commission to verify the entitlement to and amount of a tax credit.
106          (5) (a) Notwithstanding Subsection (1)(a), for taxable years beginning on or after
107     January 1, 2001, a taxpayer may not claim or carry forward a tax credit described in Subsection
108     (1)(a) in a taxable year during which the taxpayer claims or carries forward a tax credit under
109     Section 63N-2-213.
110          (b) For a taxable year other than a taxable year during which the taxpayer may not
111     claim or carry forward a tax credit in accordance with Subsection (5)(a), a taxpayer may claim
112     or carry forward a tax credit described in Subsection (1)(a):
113          (i) if the taxpayer may claim or carry forward the tax credit in accordance with
114     Subsections (1) and (2); and
115          (ii) subject to Subsections (3) and (4).
116          (6) Notwithstanding Subsection (1)(b), for taxable years beginning on or after January
117     1, 2001, a taxpayer may not claim a tax credit described in Subsection (1)(b) in a taxable year
118     during which the taxpayer claims or carries forward a tax credit under Section 63N-2-213.

119          [(7) A taxpayer may not claim or carry forward a tax credit available under this section
120     for a taxable year during which the taxpayer has claimed the targeted business income tax
121     credit available under Section 63N-2-305.]
122          Section 2. Section 59-7-614.10 is amended to read:
123          59-7-614.10. Nonrefundable enterprise zone tax credit.
124          (1) As used in this section:
125          (a) "Business entity" means a corporation that meets the definition of "business entity"
126     as that term is defined in Section 63N-2-202.
127          (b) "Office" means the Governor's Office of Economic Development created in Section
128     63N-1-201.
129          (2) Subject to the provisions of this section, a business entity may claim a
130     nonrefundable enterprise zone tax credit as described in Section 63N-2-213.
131          (3) The enterprise zone tax credit under this section is the amount listed as the tax
132     credit amount on the tax credit certificate that the office issues to the business entity for [the] a
133     taxable year ending on or before December 31, 2019.
134          (4) A business entity may carry forward a tax credit under this section for a period that
135     does not exceed the next three taxable years, if the amount of the tax credit exceeds the
136     business entity's tax liability under this chapter for that taxable year.
137          [(5) A business entity may not claim or carry forward a tax credit available under this
138     part for a taxable year during which the business entity has claimed the targeted business
139     income tax credit available under Section 63N-2-305.]
140          [(6)] (5) (a) In accordance with Section 59-7-159, the Revenue and Taxation Interim
141     Committee shall study the tax credit allowed by this section and make recommendations
142     concerning whether the tax credit should be continued, modified, or repealed.
143          (b) (i) Except as provided in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(ii), for purposes of the study
144     required by this Subsection [(6)] (5), the office shall provide by electronic means the following
145     information for each calendar year to the Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst:
146          (A) the amount of tax credits provided in each development zone;
147          (B) the number of new full-time employee positions reported to obtain tax credits in
148     each development zone;
149          (C) the amount of tax credits awarded for rehabilitating a building in each development

150     zone;
151          (D) the amount of tax credits awarded for investing in a plant, equipment, or other
152     depreciable property in each development zone;
153          (E) the information related to the tax credit contained in the office's latest report under
154     Section 63N-1-301; and
155          (F) any other information that the Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst requests.
156          (ii) (A) In providing the information described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(i), the office
157     shall redact information that identifies a recipient of a tax credit under this section.
158          (B) If, notwithstanding the redactions made under Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(ii)(A),
159     reporting the information described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(i) might disclose the identity of a
160     recipient of a tax credit, the office may file a request with the Revenue and Taxation Interim
161     Committee to provide the information described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(i) in the aggregate
162     for all development zones that receive the tax credit under this section.
163          (c) As part of the study required by this Subsection [(6)] (5), the Office of the
164     Legislative Fiscal Analyst shall report to the Revenue and Taxation Interim Committee a
165     summary and analysis of the information provided to the Office of the Legislative Fiscal
166     Analyst by the office under Subsection [(6)] (5)(b).
167          (d) The Revenue and Taxation Interim Committee shall ensure that the
168     recommendations described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(a) include an evaluation of:
169          (i) the cost of the tax credit to the state;
170          (ii) the purpose and effectiveness of the tax credit; and
171          (iii) the extent to which the state benefits from the tax credit.
172          Section 3. Section 59-10-210 is amended to read:
173          59-10-210. Fiduciary adjustments.
174          (1) A share of the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection (2) shall be added to
175     or subtracted from unadjusted income:
176          (a) of:
177          (i) a resident or nonresident estate or trust; or
178          (ii) a resident or nonresident beneficiary of a resident or nonresident estate or trust; and
179          (b) as provided in this section.
180          (2) For purposes of Subsection (1), the fiduciary adjustments are the following

181     amounts:
182          (a) the additions to and subtractions from unadjusted income of a resident or
183     nonresident estate or trust required by Section 59-10-202; and
184          (b) a tax credit claimed by a resident or nonresident estate or trust as allowed by:
185          (i) Section 59-6-102;
186          (ii) Part 10, Nonrefundable Tax Credit Act;
187          (iii) Part 11, Refundable Tax Credit Act;
188          (iv) Section 59-13-202; or
189          (v) Section 63N-2-213[; or].
190          [(vi) Section 63N-2-305.]
191          (3) (a) The respective shares of an estate or trust and its beneficiaries, including for the
192     purpose of this allocation a nonresident beneficiary, in the state fiduciary adjustments, shall be
193     allocated in proportion to their respective shares of federal distributable net income of the
194     estate or trust.
195          (b) If the estate or trust described in Subsection (3)(a) has no federal distributable net
196     income for the taxable year, the share of each beneficiary in the fiduciary adjustments shall be
197     allocated in proportion to that beneficiary's share of the estate or trust income for the taxable
198     year that is, under state law or the governing instrument, required to be distributed currently
199     plus any other amounts of that income distributed in that taxable year.
200          (c) After making the allocations required by Subsections (3)(a) and (b), any balance of
201     the fiduciary adjustments shall be allocated to the estate or trust.
202          (4) (a) The commission shall allow a fiduciary to use a method for determining the
203     allocation of the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection (2) other than the method
204     described in Subsection (3) if using the method described in Subsection (3) results in an
205     inequity:
206          (i) in allocating the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection (2); and
207          (ii) if the inequity is substantial:
208          (A) in amount; and
209          (B) in relation to the total amount of the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection
210     (2).
211          (b) In accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3, Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act, the

212     commission may make rules authorizing a fiduciary to use a method for determining the
213     allocation of the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection (2) other than the method
214     described in Subsection (3) if using the method described in Subsection (3) results in an
215     inequity:
216          (i) in allocating the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection (2); and
217          (ii) if the inequity is substantial:
218          (A) in amount; and
219          (B) in relation to the total amount of the fiduciary adjustments described in Subsection
220     (2).
221          Section 4. Section 59-10-1007 is amended to read:
222          59-10-1007. Recycling market development zones tax credit.
223          (1) For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 1996, a claimant, estate, or trust
224     in a recycling market development zone as defined in Section 63N-2-402 may claim a
225     nonrefundable tax credit as provided in this section.
226          (a) (i) There shall be allowed a tax credit of 5% of the purchase price paid for
227     machinery and equipment used directly in:
228          (A) commercial composting; or
229          (B) manufacturing facilities or plant units that:
230          (I) manufacture, process, compound, or produce recycled items of tangible personal
231     property for sale; or
232          (II) reduce or reuse postconsumer waste material.
233          (ii) The Governor's Office of Economic Development shall certify that the machinery
234     and equipment described in Subsection (1)(a)(i) are integral to the composting or recycling
235     process:
236          (A) on a form provided by the commission; and
237          (B) before a claimant, estate, or trust is allowed a tax credit under this section.
238          (iii) The Governor's Office of Economic Development shall provide a claimant, estate,
239     or trust seeking to claim a tax credit under this section with a copy of the form described in
240     Subsection (1)(a)(ii).
241          (iv) The claimant, estate, or trust described in Subsection (1)(a)(iii) shall retain a copy
242     of the form received under Subsection (1)(a)(iii).

243          (b) There shall be allowed a tax credit equal to 20% of net expenditures up to $10,000
244     to third parties for rent, wages, supplies, tools, test inventory, and utilities made by the
245     claimant, estate, or trust for establishing and operating recycling or composting technology in
246     Utah, with an annual maximum tax credit of $2,000.
247          (2) The total tax credit allowed under this section may not exceed 40% of the Utah
248     income tax liability of the claimant, estate, or trust prior to any tax credits in the taxable year of
249     purchase prior to claiming the tax credit authorized by this section.
250          (3) (a) Any tax credit not used for the taxable year in which the purchase price on
251     composting or recycling machinery and equipment was paid may be carried forward against the
252     claimant's, estate's, or trusts's tax liability under this chapter in the three succeeding taxable
253     years until the total tax credit amount is used.
254          (b) Tax credits not claimed by a claimant, estate, or trust on the claimant's, estate's, or
255     trust's tax return under this chapter within three years are forfeited.
256          (4) The commission shall make rules governing what information shall be filed with
257     the commission to verify the entitlement to and amount of a tax credit.
258          (5) (a) Notwithstanding Subsection (1)(a), for taxable years beginning on or after
259     January 1, 2001, a claimant, estate, or trust may not claim or carry forward a tax credit
260     described in Subsection (1)(a) in a taxable year during which the claimant, estate, or trust
261     claims or carries forward a tax credit under Section 63N-2-213.
262          (b) For a taxable year other than a taxable year during which the claimant, estate, or
263     trust may not claim or carry forward a tax credit in accordance with Subsection (5)(a), a
264     claimant, estate, or trust may claim or carry forward a tax credit described in Subsection (1)(a):
265          (i) if the claimant, estate, or trust may claim or carry forward the tax credit in
266     accordance with Subsections (1) and (2); and
267          (ii) subject to Subsections (3) and (4).
268          (6) Notwithstanding Subsection (1)(b), for taxable years beginning on or after January
269     1, 2001, a claimant, estate, or trust may not claim a tax credit described in Subsection (1)(b) in
270     a taxable year during which the claimant, estate, or trust claims or carries forward a tax credit
271     under Section 63N-2-213.
272          [(7) A claimant, estate, or trust may not claim or carry forward a tax credit available
273     under this section for a taxable year during which the claimant, estate, or trust has claimed the

274     targeted business income tax credit available under Section 63N-2-305.]
275          Section 5. Section 59-10-1037 is amended to read:
276          59-10-1037. Nonrefundable enterprise zone tax credit.
277          (1) As used in this section:
278          (a) "Business entity" means a claimant, estate, or trust that meets the definition of
279     "business entity" as that term is defined in Section 63N-2-202.
280          (b) "Office" means the Governor's Office of Economic Development created in Section
281     63N-1-201.
282          (2) Subject to the provisions of this section, a business entity may claim a
283     nonrefundable enterprise zone tax credit as described in Section 63N-2-213.
284          (3) The enterprise zone tax credit under this section is the amount listed as the tax
285     credit amount on the tax credit certificate that the office issues to the business entity for [the] a
286     taxable year ending on or before December 31, 2019.
287          (4) A business entity may carry forward a tax credit under this section for a period that
288     does not exceed the next three taxable years, if the amount of the tax credit exceeds the
289     business entity's tax liability under this chapter for that taxable year.
290          [(5) A business entity may not claim or carry forward a tax credit available under this
291     part for a taxable year during which the business entity has claimed the targeted business
292     income tax credit available under Section 63N-2-305.]
293          [(6)] (5) (a) In accordance with Section 59-10-137, the Revenue and Taxation Interim
294     Committee shall study the tax credit allowed by this section and make recommendations
295     concerning whether the tax credit should be continued, modified, or repealed.
296          (b) (i) Except as provided in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(ii), for purposes of the study
297     required by this Subsection [(6)] (5), the office shall provide by electronic means the following
298     information, if available to the office, for each calendar year to the Office of the Legislative
299     Fiscal Analyst:
300          (A) the amount of tax credits provided in each development zone;
301          (B) the number of new full-time employee positions reported to obtain tax credits in
302     each development zone;
303          (C) the amount of tax credits awarded for rehabilitating a building in each development
304     zone;

305          (D) the amount of tax credits awarded for investing in a plant, equipment, or other
306     depreciable property in each development zone;
307          (E) the information related to the tax credit contained in the office's latest report under
308     Section 63N-1-301; and
309          (F) other information that the Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst requests.
310          (ii) (A) In providing the information described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(i), the office
311     shall redact information that identifies a recipient of a tax credit under this section.
312          (B) If, notwithstanding the redactions made under Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(ii)(A),
313     reporting the information described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(i) might disclose the identity of a
314     recipient of a tax credit, the office may file a request with the Revenue and Taxation Interim
315     Committee to provide the information described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(b)(i) in the aggregate
316     for all development zones that receive the tax credit under this section.
317          (c) As part of the study required by this Subsection [(6)] (5), the Office of the
318     Legislative Fiscal Analyst shall report to the Revenue and Taxation Interim Committee a
319     summary and analysis of the information provided to the Office of the Legislative Fiscal
320     Analyst by the office under Subsection [(6)] (5)(b).
321          (d) The Revenue and Taxation Interim Committee shall ensure that the
322     recommendations described in Subsection [(6)] (5)(a) include an evaluation of:
323          (i) the cost of the tax credit to the state;
324          (ii) the purpose and effectiveness of the tax credit; and
325          (iii) the extent to which the state benefits from the tax credit.
326          Section 6. Section 63C-10-103 is amended to read:
327          63C-10-103. Duties.
328          (1) The board shall:
329          (a) serve as an advisory board to:
330          (i) the governor on rural economic and planning issues; and
331          (ii) the Governor's Office of Economic Development on rural economic development
332     issues;
333          (b) prepare an annual strategic plan that:
334          (i) identifies rural economic development, planning, and leadership training challenges,
335     opportunities, priorities, and objectives; and

336          (ii) includes a work plan for accomplishing the objectives referred to in Subsection
337     (1)(b)(i);
338          (c) identify local, regional, and statewide rural economic development and planning
339     priorities;
340          (d) study and take input on issues relating to local, regional, and statewide rural
341     economic development, including challenges, opportunities, best practices, policy, planning,
342     and collaboration;
343          (e) advocate for rural needs, programs, policies, opportunities, and other issues relating
344     to rural economic development and planning; and
345          [(f) review projects in enterprise zones proposed by nonprofit corporations
346     headquartered in enterprise zones as described in Subsection 63N-2-213.5(6);]
347          [(g) review applications for cash awards, grants, loans, or other financial assistance
348     under:]
349          [(i) the Rural Fast Track Program described in Section 63N-3-104; and]
350          [(ii) the Business Expansion and Retention Initiative described in Section
351     63N-3-104.5; and]
352          [(h)] (f) no later than October 1 of each year, submit to the governor, the Legislature,
353     and the Economic Development and Workforce Services Interim Committee an annual report,
354     in accordance with Section 68-3-14, that provides:
355          (i) an overview of the rural economy in the state;
356          (ii) a summary of current issues and policy matters relating to rural economic
357     development; and
358          (iii) a statement of the board's initiatives, programs, and economic development
359     priorities.
360          (2) The board may engage in activities necessary to fulfill the board's duties, including:
361          (a) propose or support rural economic development legislation; and
362          (b) create one or more subcommittees.
363          Section 7. Section 63N-2-103 is amended to read:
364          63N-2-103. Definitions.
365          As used in this part:
366          (1) "Business entity" means a person that enters into an agreement with the office to

367     initiate a new commercial project in Utah that will qualify the person to receive a tax credit
368     under Section 59-7-614.2 or 59-10-1107.
369          (2) "Community reinvestment agency" has the same meaning as that term is defined in
370     Section 17C-1-102.
371          (3) "Development zone" means an economic development zone created under Section
372     63N-2-104.
373          (4) "High paying jobs" means[:] newly created full-time employment positions where
374     the aggregate average annual gross wages of the employment positions, not including health
375     care or other paid or unpaid benefits, are at least:
376          (a) 110% of the average wage of the county in which the employment positions exist
377     for a county of the first or second class; or
378          (b) 100% of the average wage of the county in which the employment positions exist
379     for a county of the third, fourth, fifth, or sixth class.
380          [(a) with respect to a business entity, the aggregate average annual gross wages, not
381     including healthcare or other paid or unpaid benefits, of newly created full-time employment
382     positions in a business entity that are at least 110% of the average wage of a community in
383     which the employment positions will exist;]
384          [(b) with respect to a county, the aggregate average annual gross wages, not including
385     healthcare or other paid or unpaid benefits, of newly created full-time employment positions in
386     a new commercial project within the county that are at least 110% of the average wage of the
387     county in which the employment positions will exist; or]
388          [(c) with respect to a city or town, the aggregate average annual gross wages, not
389     including healthcare or other paid or unpaid benefits of newly created full-time employment
390     positions in a new commercial project within the city or town that are at least 110% of the
391     average wages of the city or town in which the employment positions will exist.]
392          (5) "Local government entity" means a county, city, or town that enters into an
393     agreement with the office to have a new commercial project that:
394          (a) is initiated within the county's, city's, or town's boundaries; and
395          (b) qualifies the county, city, or town to receive a tax credit under Section 59-7-614.2.
396          (6) (a) "New commercial project" means an economic development opportunity that
397     involves new or expanded industrial, manufacturing, distribution, or business services in Utah.

398          (b) "New commercial project" does not include retail business.
399          (7) (a) "New incremental jobs" means full-time employment positions that are filled by
400     employees who work at least 30 hours per week and that are:
401          (i) with respect to a business entity, created in addition to the baseline count of
402     employment positions that existed within the business entity before the new commercial
403     project;
404          (ii) with respect to a county, created as a result of a new commercial project with
405     respect to which the county or a community development and renewal agency seeks to claim a
406     tax credit under Section 59-7-614.2; or
407          (iii) with respect to a city or town, created as a result of a new commercial project with
408     respect to which the city, town, or a community development and renewal agency seeks to
409     claim a tax credit under Section 59-7-614.2.
410          (b) "New incremental jobs" may include full-time equivalent positions that are filled by
411     more than one employee, if each employee who works less than 30 hours per week is provided
412     benefits comparable to a full-time employee.
413          (c) "New incremental jobs" does not include jobs that are shifted from one jurisdiction
414     in the state to another jurisdiction in the state.
415          (8) "New state revenues" means:
416          (a) with respect to a business entity:
417          (i) incremental new state sales and use tax revenues that a business entity pays under
418     Title 59, Chapter 12, Sales and Use Tax Act, as a result of a new commercial project in a
419     development zone;
420          (ii) incremental new state tax revenues that a business entity pays as a result of a new
421     commercial project in a development zone under:
422          (A) Title 59, Chapter 7, Corporate Franchise and Income Taxes;
423          (B) Title 59, Chapter 10, Part 1, Determination and Reporting of Tax Liability and
424     Information;
425          (C) Title 59, Chapter 10, Part 2, Trusts and Estates;
426          (D) Title 59, Chapter 10, Part 4, Withholding of Tax; or
427          (E) a combination of Subsections (8)(a)(ii)(A) through (D);
428          (iii) incremental new state tax revenues paid as individual income taxes under Title 59,

429     Chapter 10, Part 1, Determination and Reporting of Tax Liability and Information, by
430     employees of a new or expanded industrial, manufacturing, distribution, or business service
431     within a new commercial project as evidenced by payroll records that indicate the amount of
432     employee income taxes withheld and transmitted to the State Tax Commission by the new or
433     expanded industrial, manufacturing, distribution, or business service within the new
434     commercial project; or
435          (iv) a combination of Subsections (8)(a)(i) through (iii); or
436          (b) with respect to a local government entity:
437          (i) incremental new state sales and use tax revenues that are collected under Title 59,
438     Chapter 12, Sales and Use Tax Act, as a result of a new commercial project in a development
439     zone;
440          (ii) incremental new state tax revenues that are collected as a result of a new
441     commercial project in a development zone under:
442          (A) Title 59, Chapter 7, Corporate Franchise and Income Taxes;
443          (B) Title 59, Chapter 10, Part 1, Determination and Reporting of Tax Liability and
444     Information;
445          (C) Title 59, Chapter 10, Part 2, Trusts and Estates;
446          (D) Title 59, Chapter 10, Part 4, Withholding of Tax; or
447          (E) a combination of Subsections (8)(b)(ii)(A) through (D);
448          (iii) incremental new state tax revenues paid as individual income taxes under Title 59,
449     Chapter 10, Part 1, Determination and Reporting of Tax Liability and Information, by
450     employees of a new or expanded industrial, manufacturing, distribution, or business service
451     within a new commercial project as evidenced by payroll records that indicate the amount of
452     employee income taxes withheld and transmitted to the State Tax Commission by the new or
453     expanded industrial, manufacturing, distribution, or business service within the new
454     commercial project; or
455          (iv) a combination of Subsections (8)(b)(i) through (iii).
456          (9) "Significant capital investment" means an amount of at least $10,000,000 to
457     purchase capital or fixed assets, which may include real property, personal property, and other
458     fixtures related to a new commercial project:
459          (a) that represents an expansion of existing operations in the state; or

460          (b) that maintains or increases the business entity's existing work force in the state.
461          (10) "Tax credit" means an economic development tax credit created by Section
462     59-7-614.2 or 59-10-1107.
463          (11) "Tax credit amount" means the amount the office lists as a tax credit on a tax
464     credit certificate for a taxable year.
465          (12) "Tax credit certificate" means a certificate issued by the office that:
466          (a) lists the name of the business entity, local government entity, or community
467     development and renewal agency to which the office authorizes a tax credit;
468          (b) lists the business entity's, local government entity's, or community development and
469     renewal agency's taxpayer identification number;
470          (c) lists the amount of tax credit that the office authorizes the business entity, local
471     government entity, or community development and renewal agency for the taxable year; and
472          (d) may include other information as determined by the office.
473          Section 8. Section 63N-2-203 is amended to read:
474          63N-2-203. Powers of the office.
475          The office shall:
476          (1) monitor the implementation and operation of this part and conduct a continuing
477     evaluation of the progress made in the enterprise zones;
478          (2) evaluate an application for designation as an enterprise zone from a county
479     applicant or a municipal applicant and determine if the applicant qualifies for that designation;
480          (3) provide technical assistance to county applicants and municipal applicants in
481     developing applications for designation as enterprise zones;
482          (4) assist county applicants and municipal applicants designated as enterprise zones in
483     obtaining assistance from the federal government and agencies of the state;
484          (5) assist a qualified business entity in obtaining the benefits of an incentive or
485     inducement program authorized by this part; and
486          (6) as part of the annual written report described in Section 63N-1-301, prepare an
487     annual evaluation that provides:
488          (a) based on data from the State Tax Commission, the total amount of tax credits
489     claimed under this part;
490          (b) the total amount awarded in tax credits for each development zone;

491          (c) the number of new full-time employee positions reported to obtain tax credits in
492     each development zone;
493          (d) the amount of tax credits awarded for rehabilitating a building in each development
494     zone;
495          (e) the amount of tax credits awarded for investing in a plant, equipment, or other
496     depreciable property in each development zone; and
497          [(f) the list of approved projects under Section 63N-2-213.5 and the aggregate value of
498     the tax credit certificates issued related to contributions to those approved projects; and]
499          [(g)] (f) recommendations regarding the effectiveness of the program and any
500     suggestions for legislation.
501          Section 9. Section 63N-2-204 is amended to read:
502          63N-2-204. Criteria for designation of enterprise zones -- Application.
503          (1) A county applicant seeking designation as an enterprise zone shall file an
504     application with the office that, in addition to complying with the other requirements of this
505     part:
506          (a) verifies that the county has a population of not more than 70,000; and
507          (b) provides clear evidence of the need for development in the county.
508          (2) A municipal applicant seeking designation as an enterprise zone shall file an
509     application with the office that, in addition to complying with other requirements of this part:
510          (a) verifies that the municipality has a population that does not exceed 20,000;
511          (b) verifies that the municipality is within a county that has a population of not more
512     than 70,000; and
513          (c) provides clear evidence of the need for development in the municipality.
514          (3) An application filed under Subsection (1) or (2) shall be in a form and in
515     accordance with procedures approved by the office, and shall include the following
516     information:
517          (a) a plan developed by the county applicant or municipal applicant that identifies local
518     contributions meeting the requirements of Section 63N-2-205;
519          (b) the county applicant or municipal applicant has a development plan that outlines:
520          (i) the types of investment and development within the zone that the county applicant
521     or municipal applicant expects to take place if the incentives specified in this part are provided;

522          (ii) the specific investment or development reasonably expected to take place;
523          (iii) any commitments obtained from businesses;
524          (iv) the projected number of jobs that will be created and the anticipated wage level of
525     those jobs;
526          (v) any proposed emphasis on the type of jobs created, including any affirmative action
527     plans; and
528          (vi) a copy of the county applicant's or municipal applicant's economic development
529     plan to demonstrate coordination between the zone and overall county or municipal goals;
530          (c) the county applicant's or municipal applicant's proposed means of assessing the
531     effectiveness of the development plan or other programs within the zone once they have been
532     implemented within the zone;
533          (d) any additional information required by the office; and
534          (e) any additional information the county applicant or municipal applicant considers
535     relevant to its designation as an enterprise zone.
536          (4) On or after January 1, 2019, no new enterprise zones shall be designated.
537          Section 10. Section 63N-2-208 is amended to read:
538          63N-2-208. Duration of designation.
539          (1) Each enterprise zone has a duration of five years[, at the end of which the county
540     may reapply for the designation].
541          (2) On or after January 1, 2019, a county may not reapply for an enterprise zone
542     designation for an enterprise zone that has reached the end of the enterprise zone's five-year
543     duration.
544          Section 11. Section 63N-2-213 is amended to read:
545          63N-2-213. State tax credits.
546          (1) (a) The office shall certify a business entity's eligibility for a tax credit described in
547     this section.
548          (b) A business entity may not receive a tax credit under this section for a taxable year
549     beginning on or after January 1, 2020.
550          (2) A business entity seeking to receive a tax credit as provided in this section shall
551     provide the office with:
552          (a) an application for a tax credit certificate in a form approved by the office, including

553     a certification, by an officer of the business entity, of a signature on the application; and
554          (b) documentation that demonstrates the business entity has met the requirements to
555     receive the tax credit.
556          (3) If, after review of an application and documentation provided by a business entity
557     as described in Subsection (2), the office determines that the application and documentation are
558     inadequate to provide a reasonable justification for authorizing the tax credit, the office shall:
559          (a) deny the tax credit; or
560          (b) inform the business entity that the application or documentation was inadequate
561     and ask the business entity to submit additional documentation.
562          (4) If, after review of an application and documentation provided by a business entity
563     as described in Subsection (2), the office determines that the application and documentation
564     provide reasonable justification for authorizing a tax credit, the office shall:
565          (a) determine the amount of the tax credit to be granted to the business entity;
566          (b) issue a tax credit certificate to the business entity; and
567          (c) provide a duplicate copy of the tax credit certificate to the State Tax Commission.
568          (5) A business entity may not claim a tax credit under this section unless the business
569     entity has a tax credit certificate issued by the office.
570          (6) In accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3, Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act, the
571     office shall make rules describing:
572          (a) the form and content of an application for a tax credit under this section;
573          (b) the documentation requirements for a business entity to receive a tax credit
574     certificate under this section; and
575          (c) administration of the program, including relevant timelines and deadlines.
576          (7) [Subject] For a taxable year that ends on or before December 31, 2019, and subject
577     to the limitations of Subsections (8) through (10), [and] if the requirements of this part are met,
578     the following nonrefundable tax credits against a tax under Title 59, Chapter 7, Corporate
579     Franchise and Income Taxes, or Title 59, Chapter 10, Individual Income Tax Act, are
580     applicable in an enterprise zone:
581          (a) a tax credit of $750 may be claimed by a business entity for each new full-time
582     employee position created within the enterprise zone;
583          (b) an additional $500 tax credit may be claimed if the new full-time employee position

584     created within the enterprise zone pays at least 125% of:
585          (i) the county average monthly nonagricultural payroll wage for the respective industry
586     as determined by the Department of Workforce Services; or
587          (ii) if the county average monthly nonagricultural payroll wage is not available for the
588     respective industry, the total average monthly nonagricultural payroll wage in the respective
589     county where the enterprise zone is located;
590          (c) an additional tax credit of $750 may be claimed if the new full-time employee
591     position created within the enterprise zone is in a business entity that adds value to agricultural
592     commodities through manufacturing or processing;
593          (d) an additional tax credit of $200 may be claimed for two consecutive years for each
594     new full-time employee position created within the enterprise zone that is filled by an
595     employee who is insured under an employer-sponsored health insurance program if the
596     employer pays at least 50% of the premium cost for the year for which the credit is claimed;
597          (e) a tax credit of 25% of the first $200,000 spent on rehabilitating a building in the
598     enterprise zone that has been vacant for two years or more; and
599          (f) an annual investment tax credit of 10% of the first $250,000 in investment, and 5%
600     of the next $1,000,000 qualifying investment in plant, equipment, or other depreciable
601     property.
602          (8) (a) Subject to the limitations of Subsection (8)(b), a business entity claiming a tax
603     credit under Subsections (7)(a) through (d) may claim the tax credit for no more than 30
604     full-time employee positions in a taxable year.
605          (b) A business entity that received a tax credit for one or more new full-time employee
606     positions under Subsections (7)(a) through (d) in a prior taxable year may claim a tax credit for
607     a new full-time employee position in a subsequent taxable year under Subsections (7)(a)
608     through (d) if:
609          (i) the business entity has created a new full-time position within the enterprise zone;
610     and
611          (ii) the total number of full-time employee positions at the business entity at any point
612     during the tax year for which the tax credit is being claimed is greater than the highest number
613     of full-time employee positions that existed at the business entity in the previous three taxable
614     years.

615          (c) Construction jobs are not eligible for the tax credits under Subsections (7)(a)
616     through (d).
617          (9) If the amount of a tax credit under this section exceeds a business entity's tax
618     liability under this chapter for a taxable year, the business entity may carry forward the amount
619     of the tax credit exceeding the liability for a period that does not exceed the next three taxable
620     years.
621          (10) Tax credits under Subsections (7)(a) through (f) may not be claimed by a business
622     entity primarily engaged in retail trade or by a public utilities business.
623          (11) A business entity that has no employees:
624          (a) may not claim tax credits under Subsections (7)(a) through (d); and
625          (b) may claim tax credits under Subsections (7)(e) through (f).
626          [(12) A business entity may not claim or carry forward a tax credit available under this
627     part for a taxable year during which the business entity has claimed the targeted business
628     income tax credit available under Section 63N-2-305.]
629          [(13)] (12) (a) On or before November 30, 2018, and every three years after 2018, the
630     Revenue and Taxation Interim Committee shall review the tax credits provided by this section
631     and make recommendations concerning whether the tax credits should be continued, modified,
632     or repealed.
633          (b) In conducting the review required by Subsection [(13)] (12)(a), the Revenue and
634     Taxation Interim Committee shall:
635          (i) schedule time on at least one committee agenda to conduct the review;
636          (ii) invite state agencies, individuals, and organizations concerned with the credits
637     under review to provide testimony;
638          (iii) ensure that the recommendations described in this section include an evaluation of:
639          (A) the cost of the tax credits to the state;
640          (B) the purpose and effectiveness of the tax credits; and
641          (C) the extent to which the state benefits from the tax credits; and
642          (iv) undertake other review efforts as determined by the chairs of the Revenue and
643     Taxation Interim Committee.
644          Section 12. Section 63N-2-403 is amended to read:
645          63N-2-403. Duties of the office.

646          The office shall:
647          (1) facilitate recycling development zones through state support of county incentives
648     which encourage development of manufacturing enterprises that use recycling materials
649     currently collected;
650          (2) evaluate an application from a county or municipality executive authority to be
651     designated as a recycling market development zone and determine if the county or municipality
652     qualifies for that designation;
653          (3) provide technical assistance to municipalities and counties in developing
654     applications for designation as a recycling market development zone;
655          (4) assist counties and municipalities designated as recycling market development
656     zones in obtaining assistance from the federal government and agencies of the state;
657          (5) assist a qualified business in obtaining the benefits of an incentive or inducement
658     program authorized by this part;
659          (6) monitor the implementation and operation of this part and conduct a continuing
660     evaluation of the progress made in the recycling market development zone; and
661          (7) include in the annual written report described in Section [63N-2-301] 63N-1-301,
662     an evaluation of the effectiveness of the program and recommendations for legislation.
663          Section 13. Section 63N-2-705 is amended to read:
664          63N-2-705. Reporting.
665          The office shall provide the following information in the annual written report
666     described in Section [63N-2-301] 63N-1-301:
667          (1) the office's success in attracting alternative energy manufacturing projects to the
668     state and the resulting increase in new state revenues under this part;
669          (2) the amount of tax credits the office has granted or will grant and the time period
670     during which the tax credits have been or will be granted; and
671          (3) the economic impact on the state by comparing new state revenues to tax credits
672     that have been or will be granted under this part.
673          Section 14. Section 63N-4-501 is enacted to read:
674     
Part 5. Rural County Economic Development Grant Program

675          63N-4-501. Title.
676          This part is known as the "Rural County Economic Development Grant Program."

677          Section 15. Section 63N-4-502 is enacted to read:
678          63N-4-502. Definitions.
679          As used in this part:
680          (1) "Grant" means a grant available under the Rural County Economic Development
681     Grant Program created in this part.
682          (2) "Grant program" means the Rural County Economic Development Grant Program
683     created in Section 63N-4-503.
684          (3) "Rural county" means a county of the third class, fourth class, fifth class, or sixth
685     class.
686          (4) "Rural partnership board" means the Governor's Rural Partnership Board created in
687     Section 63C-10-102.
688          (5) "Qualifying strategic economic development plan" means a rural county economic
689     development plan created by a rural county, or by a rural county with the assistance of the
690     Office of Rural Development, to address the economic development needs of the rural county
691     and which has been reviewed and approved by GOED.
692          Section 16. Section 63N-4-503 is enacted to read:
693          63N-4-503. Creation and purpose of the Rural County Economic Development
694     Grant Program.
695          (1) There is created the Rural County Economic Development Grant Program.
696          (2) The grant program shall be administered by GOED and the Office of Rural
697     Development.
698          (3) In administering the grant program, GOED and the Office of Rural Development
699     shall award grants to rural counties to address the economic development needs of rural
700     counties in accordance with the provisions of this part, which needs may include:
701          (a) training and technical assistance, such as project planning, business counseling and
702     training, market research, professional and technical reports, or product or service
703     improvements;
704          (b) economic development funding for specific communities within a rural county;
705          (c) technology-based economic development;
706          (d) feasibility studies and business plans;
707          (e) the creation or support of business incubators;

708          (f) long-term strategic planning for specific business sectors; and
709          (g) creating or improving a rural county's qualifying strategic economic development
710     plan.
711          Section 17. Section 63N-4-504 is enacted to read:
712          63N-4-504. Requirements for awarding a grant.
713          (1) In accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3, Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act,
714     GOED shall make rules establishing the eligibility and reporting criteria for a rural county to
715     receive a grant under this part, including:
716          (a) the form and process for a rural county submitting an application to the Office of
717     Rural Development for a grant;
718          (b) the method of scoring and prioritizing grant program applications from rural
719     counties;
720          (c) the reporting, auditing, and post-performance requirements for a rural county that
721     receives a grant under the grant program; and
722          (d) any deadlines that shall be met by a rural county when applying for a grant under
723     the grant program.
724          (2) In determining the award of a grant, GOED and the Office of Rural Development
725     may prioritize applications that demonstrate any combination of the following:
726          (a) that the county has or is actively pursuing the creation of an effective qualifying
727     strategic economic development plan;
728          (b) consistency with local economic development priorities;
729          (c) an effective plan to measure and report results;
730          (d) economic need;
731          (e) utilization of local financial or in-kind resources in combination with a grant;
732          (f) evidence that jobs will be created; and
733          (g) evidence that there will be a positive return on investment.
734          (3) Subject to legislative appropriation, a grant may only be awarded to a rural county
735     by the executive director after the following requirements have been met:
736          (a) the Office of Rural Development has scored and prioritized one or more grant
737     applications from rural counties in accordance with this part and rules made by the office as
738     described in Subsection (1);

739          (b) the results of the scoring and prioritization of one or more grant applications are
740     provided to the rural partnership board for the rural partnership board's review and
741     recommendations related to awarding grants under the grant program;
742          (c) the rural partnership board may reject an application for a grant if the rural
743     partnership board determines that the proposed use of the grant would lack positive economic
744     impact, is inconsistent with the state economic development strategy, or would negatively
745     impact municipalities within the rural county; and
746          (d) after the rural partnership board provides a positive recommendation for one or
747     more grant applications, the grant applications are provided for final approval to the Board of
748     Business and Economic Development.
749          Section 18. Section 63N-4-505 is enacted to read:
750          63N-4-505. Indian tribes -- Application.
751          (1) For purposes of this section:
752          (a) "Indian tribe" has the same meaning as defined in Subsection 9-9-402(6).
753          (b) "Tribal applicant" means the governing authority of an Indian tribe that applies for
754     a grant in accordance with Subsection (2) and the grant program created in Section 63N-4-503.
755          (2) (a) An Indian tribe may apply for a grant under the grant program.
756          (b) A tribal applicant shall follow the application procedure for a rural county as
757     described in this part.
758          Section 19. Section 63N-4-506 is enacted to read:
759          63N-4-506. Reporting.
760          GOED shall include in the annual written report described in Section 63N-1-301, a
761     report describing:
762          (1) grant recipients and the amounts of grant money received by each grant recipient;
763          (2) an evaluation of the effectiveness of awarded grants in improving economic
764     development in rural counties receiving grants; and
765          (3) any recommendations to improve or modify the grant program.
766          Section 20. Repealer.
767          This bill repeals:
768          Section 59-7-614.11, Nonrefundable nonprofit contribution tax credit.
769          Section 59-10-1039, Nonrefundable nonprofit contribution tax credit.

770          Section 63N-2-213.5, State tax credits for contributions to a nonprofit corporation.
771          Section 63N-2-301, Title.
772          Section 63N-2-302, Definitions.
773          Section 63N-2-303, Duties of the office.
774          Section 63N-2-304, Application for targeted business income tax credit.
775          Section 63N-2-305, Targeted business income tax credit structure -- Revenue and
776     Taxation Interim Committee study.
777          Section 63N-3-104, Rural Fast Track Program -- Creation -- Funding --
778     Qualifications for program participation -- Awards -- Reports.
779          Section 63N-3-104.5, Business Expansion and Retention Initiative -- Creation --
780     Funding -- Qualifications for program participation -- Awards -- Reports.
781          Section 21. Appropriations.
782          The following sums of money are appropriated for the fiscal year beginning July 1,
783     2019, and ending June 30, 2020. These are additions to amounts previously appropriated for
784     fiscal year 2020. Under the terms and conditions of Title 63J, Chapter 1, Budgetary Procedures
785     Act, the Legislature appropriates the following sums of money from the funds or accounts
786     indicated for the use and support of the government of the state of Utah.
787     ITEM 1
788          To the Governor's Office of Economic Development -- Rural County Economic
789               Development Grant Program
790               From General Fund
$8,000,000

791               From General Fund, One-time
($6,000,000)

792               Schedule of Programs:
793                    Rural County Economic Development
794                         Grant Program               $2,000,000
795          Section 22. Retrospective operation.
796          The repeal of Sections 59-7-614.11, 59-10-1039, 63N-2-213.5, 63N-2-301, 63N-2-302,
797     63N-2-303, 63N-2-304, and 63N-2-305 in this bill have retrospective operation for a taxable
798     year beginning on or after January 1, 2019.