Senator Daniel McCay proposes the following substitute bill:


1     
PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE DISTRICT AMENDMENTS

2     
2020 GENERAL SESSION

3     
STATE OF UTAH

4     
Chief Sponsor: Daniel McCay

5     
House Sponsor: James A. Dunnigan

6     

7     LONG TITLE
8     General Description:
9          This bill modifies provisions in the Public Infrastructure District Act.
10     Highlighted Provisions:
11          This bill:
12          ▸     modifies requirements regarding the creation of a public infrastructure district;
13          ▸     allows a public infrastructure district to annex or withdraw property without the
14     consent of the creating entity if authorized in the district's governing document;
15          ▸     exempts a public infrastructure district from certain notice and hearing requirements
16     upon:
17               •     levying a property tax if certain conditions are met; or
18               •     amending a property tax levy rate limitation in the district's governing
19     document; and
20          ▸     makes technical and conforming changes.
21     Money Appropriated in this Bill:
22          None
23     Other Special Clauses:
24          None
25     Utah Code Sections Affected:

26     AMENDS:
27          17B-2a-1202, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2019, Chapter 490
28          17B-2a-1204, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2019, Chapter 490
29          17B-2a-1205, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2019, Chapter 490
30          17B-2a-1207, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2019, Chapter 490
31     

32     Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
33          Section 1. Section 17B-2a-1202 is amended to read:
34          17B-2a-1202. Definitions.
35          As used in this part:
36          (1) "Board" means the board of trustees of a public infrastructure district.
37          (2) "Creating entity" means the county or municipality that approves of the creation of
38     the public infrastructure district.
39          (3) "District applicant" means the person proposing the creation of the public
40     infrastructure district.
41          (4) "Division" means a division of a public infrastructure district:
42          (a) that is relatively equal in number of eligible voters or potential eligible voters to all
43     other divisions within the public infrastructure district, taking into account existing or potential
44     developments which, when completed, would increase or decrease the population within the
45     public infrastructure district; and
46          (b) which a member of the board represents.
47          (5) "Governing document" means the document governing the public infrastructure
48     district to which the creating entity agrees before the creation of the public infrastructure
49     district, as amended from time to time, and subject to the limitations of Chapter 1, Provisions
50     Applicable to All Local Districts, and this part.
51          (6) (a) "Limited tax bond" means a bond:
52          (i) that is directly payable from and secured by ad valorem property taxes that are
53     levied:
54          (A) by the public infrastructure district that issues the bond; and
55          (B) on taxable property within the district;
56          (ii) that is a general obligation of the public infrastructure district; and

57          (iii) for which the ad valorem property tax levy for repayment of the bond does not
58     exceed the [mill] property tax levy rate limit established under Section 17B-2a-1209 for any
59     fiscal year, except as provided in Subsection 17B-2a-1207(8).
60          (b) "Limited tax bond" does not include:
61          (i) a short-term bond;
62          (ii) a tax and revenue anticipation bond; or
63          (iii) a special assessment bond.
64          Section 2. Section 17B-2a-1204 is amended to read:
65          17B-2a-1204. Creation -- Annexation or withdrawal of property.
66          (1) [In] Except as provided in Subsection (2), in addition to the provisions regarding
67     creation of a local district in Chapter 1, Provisions Applicable to All Local Districts, a public
68     infrastructure district may not be created unless:
69          (a) if there are any registered voters within the applicable area, a petition is filed with
70     the creating entity that contains the signatures of 100% of registered voters within the
71     applicable area approving the creation of the public infrastructure district; and
72          (b) a petition is filed with the creating entity that contains the signatures of 100% of
73     surface property owners within the applicable area consenting to the creation of the public
74     infrastructure district.
75          (2) (a) The [election requirement of Section 17B-1-214 does] following do not apply to
76     [a petition meeting the requirements of Subsection (1).]the creation of a public infrastructure
77     district:
78          (i) Section 17B-1-203;
79          (ii) Section 17B-1-204;
80          (iii) Subsection 17B-1-208(2);
81          (iv) Section 17B-1-212; or
82          (v) Section 17B-1-214.
83          (b) The protest period described in Section 17B-1-213 may be waived in whole or in
84     part with the consent of:
85          (i) 100% of registered voters within the applicable area approving the creation of the
86     public infrastructure district; and
87          (ii) 100% of the surface property owners within the applicable area approving the

88     creation of the public infrastructure district.
89          (c) If the protest period is waived under Subsection (2)(b), a resolution approving the
90     creation of the public infrastructure district may be adopted in accordance with Subsection
91     17B-1-213(5).
92          (d) A petition meeting the requirements of Subsection (1):
93          (i) may be certified under Section 17B-1-209; and
94          (ii) shall be filed with the lieutenant governor in accordance with Subsection
95     17B-1-215(1)(b)(iii).
96          (3) (a) Notwithstanding Chapter 1, Part 4, Annexation, an area outside of the
97     boundaries of a public infrastructure district may be annexed into the public infrastructure
98     district after:
99          (i) (A) adoption of resolutions of the board and the creating entity, each approving of
100     the annexation; or
101          (B) adoption of a governing document that authorizes the board to annex an area
102     outside of the boundaries of the public infrastructure district without the consent of the creating
103     entity;
104          (ii) if there are any registered voters within the area proposed to be annexed, a petition
105     is filed with the creating entity that contains the signatures of 100% of registered voters within
106     the area and approves of the annexation into the public infrastructure district; and
107          (iii) a petition is filed with the creating entity that contains the signatures of 100% of
108     surface property owners within the area proposed to be annexed and consents to the annexation
109     into the public infrastructure district.
110          (b) Upon meeting the requirements of Subsection (3)(a), the board shall comply with
111     the resolution and filing requirements of Subsections 17B-1-414(1) and (2).
112          [(c) (i)] (4) (a) Notwithstanding Chapter 1, Part 5, Withdrawal, property may be
113     withdrawn from a public infrastructure district after:
114          (i) (A) adoption of resolutions of the board and the creating entity, each approving of
115     the [annexation;] withdrawal; or
116          (B) adoption of a governing document that authorizes the board to withdraw property
117     from the public infrastructure district without the consent of the creating entity;
118          [(B)] (ii) if there are any registered voters within the area proposed to be withdrawn, a

119     petition is filed with the creating entity that contains the signatures of 100% of registered voters
120     within the area and approves of the withdrawal from the public infrastructure district; and
121          [(C)] (iii) a petition is filed with the creating entity that contains the signatures of 100%
122     of surface property owners within the area proposed to be withdrawn and consents to the
123     withdrawal from the public infrastructure district.
124          [(ii)] (b) If any bonds that the public infrastructure district issues are allocable to the
125     area to be withdrawn remain unpaid at the time of the proposed withdrawal, the property
126     remains subject to any taxes, fees, or assessments that the public infrastructure district imposes
127     until the bonds or any associated refunding bonds are paid.
128          [(d)] (c) Upon meeting the requirements of [Subsection (3)(c)] Subsections (4)(a) and
129     (b), the board shall comply with the requirements of Section 17B-1-512.
130          [(4)] (5) The creating entity may impose limitations on the powers of the public
131     infrastructure district through the governing document.
132          [(5)] (6) (a) A public infrastructure district is separate and distinct from the creating
133     entity.
134          (b) (i) Except as provided in Subsection [(5)] (6)(b)(ii), any financial burden of a
135     public infrastructure district:
136          (A) is borne solely by the public infrastructure district; and
137          (B) is not borne by the creating entity or any municipality, county, the state, or any
138     other political subdivision.
139          (ii) Notwithstanding Subsection [(5)] (6)(b)(i) and Section 17B-1-216, the governing
140     document may require:
141          (A) the district applicant to bear the initial costs of the public infrastructure district;
142     and
143          (B) the public infrastructure district to reimburse the district applicant for the initial
144     costs the creating entity bears.
145          (c) Any liability, judgment, or claim against a public infrastructure district:
146          (i) is the sole responsibility of the public infrastructure district; and
147          (ii) does not constitute a liability, judgment, or claim against the creating entity, the
148     state, or any municipality, county, or other political subdivision.
149          (d) (i) (A) The public infrastructure district solely bears the responsibility of any

150     collection, enforcement, or foreclosure proceeding with regard to any tax, fee, or assessment
151     the public infrastructure district imposes.
152          (B) The creating entity does not bear the responsibility described in Subsection [(5)]
153     (6)(d)(i)(A).
154          (ii) A public infrastructure district, and not the creating entity, shall undertake the
155     enforcement responsibility described in, as applicable, Subsection [(5)] (6)(d)(i) in accordance
156     with Title 59, Chapter 2, Property Tax Act, or Title 11, Chapter 42, Assessment Area Act.
157          [(6)] (7) The creating entity may establish criteria in determining whether to approve or
158     disapprove of the creation of a public infrastructure district, including:
159          (a) historical performance of the district applicant;
160          (b) compliance with the creating entity's master plan;
161          (c) credit worthiness of the district applicant;
162          (d) plan of finance of the public infrastructure district; and
163          (e) proposed development within the public infrastructure district.
164          [(7)] (8) (a) The creation of a public infrastructure district is subject to the sole
165     discretion of the creating entity responsible for approving or rejecting the creation of the public
166     infrastructure district.
167          (b) The proposed creating entity bears no liability for rejecting the proposed creation of
168     a public infrastructure district.
169          Section 3. Section 17B-2a-1205 is amended to read:
170          17B-2a-1205. Public infrastructure district board -- Governing document.
171          (1) The legislative body of the creating entity [that approves the creation of a public
172     infrastructure district] shall appoint the members of the board, in accordance with the
173     governing document.
174          (2) (a) Unless otherwise limited in the governing document and except as provided in
175     Subsection (2)(b), the initial term of each member of the board is four years.
176          (b) Notwithstanding Subsection (2)(a), approximately half of the members of the initial
177     board shall serve a six-year term so that, after the expiration of the initial term, the term of
178     approximately half the board members expires every two years.
179          (c) A board may elect that a majority of the board serve an initial term of six years.
180          (d) After the initial term, the term of each member of the board is four years.

181          (3) (a) Notwithstanding Subsection 17B-1-302(1)(b), a board member is not required
182     to be a resident within the boundaries of the public infrastructure district if:
183          (i) all of the surface property owners consent to the waiver of the residency
184     requirement;
185          (ii) there are no residents within the boundaries of the public infrastructure district;
186          (iii) no qualified candidate timely files to be considered for appointment to the board;
187     or
188          (iv) no qualified individual files a declaration of candidacy for a board position in
189     accordance with Subsection 17B-1-306(4).
190          (b) Except under the circumstances described in Subsection (3)(a)(iii) or (iv), the
191     residency requirement in Subsection 17B-1-302(1)(b) is applicable to any board member
192     elected for a division or board position that has transitioned from an appointed to an elected
193     board member in accordance with this section.
194          (c) An individual who is not a resident within the boundaries of the public
195     infrastructure district may not serve as a board member unless the individual is:
196          (i) an owner of land or an agent or officer of the owner of land within the boundaries of
197     the public infrastructure district; and
198          (ii) a registered voter at the individual's primary residence.
199          (4) (a) A governing document may provide for a transition from legislative body
200     appointment under Subsection (1) to a method of election by registered voters based upon
201     milestones or events that the governing document identifies, including a milestone for each
202     division or individual board position providing that when the milestone is reached:
203          (i) for a division, the registered voters of the division elect a member of the board in
204     place of an appointed member at the next municipal general election for the board position; or
205          (ii) for an at large board position established in the governing document, the registered
206     voters of the public infrastructure district elect a member of the board in place of an appointed
207     member at the next municipal general election for the board position.
208          (b) Regardless of whether a board member is elected under Subsection (4)(a), the
209     position of each remaining board member shall continue to be appointed under Subsection (1)
210     until the member's respective division or board position surpasses the density milestone
211     described in the governing document.

212          (5) (a) Subject to Subsection (5)(c), the board may, in the board's discretion but no
213     more frequently than every four years, reestablish the boundaries of each division so that each
214     division that has reached a milestone specified in the governing document, as described in
215     Subsection (4)(a), has, as nearly as possible, the same number of eligible voters.
216          (b) In reestablishing division boundaries under Subsection (5)(a), the board shall
217     consider existing or potential developments within the divisions which, when completed,
218     would increase or decrease the number of eligible voters within the division.
219          (c) The governing document may prohibit the board from reestablishing, without the
220     consent of the creating entity, the division boundaries as described in Subsection (5)(a).
221          (6) The public infrastructure district may not compensate a board member for the
222     member's service on the board under Section 17B-1-307 unless the board member is a resident
223     within the boundaries of the public infrastructure district.
224          (7) The governing document shall:
225          (a) include a boundary description and a map of the public infrastructure district;
226          (b) state the number of board members;
227          (c) describe any divisions of the public infrastructure district;
228          (d) establish any applicable [mill] property tax levy rate limit for the public
229     infrastructure district;
230          (e) establish any applicable limitation on the principal amount of indebtedness for the
231     public infrastructure district; and
232          (f) include other information that the public infrastructure district or the creating entity
233     determines to be necessary or advisable.
234          (8) (a) Except as provided in Subsection (8)(b), the board and the governing body of
235     the creating entity may amend a governing document by each adopting a resolution that
236     approves the amended governing document.
237          [(b) Notwithstanding Subsection (8)(a), any amendment to a property tax mill
238     limitation requires:]
239          [(i) before the adoption of the resolution of the creating entity described in Subsection
240     (8)(a), the public infrastructure district to comply with the notice and public hearing
241     requirements of Section 59-2-919, with at least one member of the governing body of the
242     creating entity attending the public hearing required in Subsection 59-2-919(3)(a)(v) or (4)(b);

243     or]
244          [(ii) the consent of:]
245          [(A) 100% of surface property owners within the boundaries of the public
246     infrastructure district; and]
247          [(B) 100% of the registered voters, if any, within the boundaries of the public
248     infrastructure district.]
249          (b) Notwithstanding Subsection (8)(a), any amendment to a property tax levy rate
250     limitation requires the consent of:
251          (i) 100% of surface property owners within the boundaries of the public infrastructure
252     district; and
253          (ii) 100% of the registered voters, if any, within the boundaries of the public
254     infrastructure district.
255          (9) A board member is not in violation of Section 67-16-9 if the board member:
256          (a) discloses a business relationship in accordance with Sections 67-16-7 and 67-16-8
257     and files the disclosure with the creating entity:
258          (i) before any appointment or election; and
259          (ii) upon any significant change in the business relationship; and
260          (b) conducts the affairs of the public infrastructure district in accordance with this title
261     and any parameters described in the governing document.
262          Section 4. Section 17B-2a-1207 is amended to read:
263          17B-2a-1207. Public infrastructure district bonds.
264          (1) A public infrastructure district may issue negotiable bonds for the purposes
265     described in Section 17B-2a-1206, as provided in, as applicable:
266          (a) Title 11, Chapter 14, Local Government Bonding Act;
267          (b) Title 11, Chapter 27, Utah Refunding Bond Act;
268          (c) Title 11, Chapter 42, Assessment Area Act; and
269          (d) this section.
270          (2) A public infrastructure district bond:
271          (a) shall mature within 40 years of the date of issuance; and
272          (b) may not be secured by any improvement or facility paid for by the public
273     infrastructure district.

274          (3) (a) A public infrastructure district may issue a limited tax bond, in the same manner
275     as a general obligation bond:
276          (i) with the consent of 100% of surface property owners within the boundaries of the
277     public infrastructure district and 100% of the registered voters, if any, within the boundaries of
278     the proposed public infrastructure district; or
279          (ii) upon approval of a majority of the registered voters within the boundaries of the
280     public infrastructure district voting in an election held for that purpose under Title 11, Chapter
281     14, Local Government Bonding Act.
282          (b) A limited tax bond described in Subsection (3)(a):
283          (i) is not subject to the limitation on a general obligation bond described in Subsection
284     17B-1-1102(4)(a)(xii); and
285          (ii) is subject to a limitation, if any, on the principal amount of indebtedness as
286     described in the governing document.
287          (c) Unless limited tax bonds are initially purchased exclusively by one or more
288     qualified institutional buyers as defined in Rule 144A, 17 C.F.R. Sec. 230.144A, the public
289     infrastructure district may only issue limited tax bonds in denominations of not less than
290     $500,000, and in integral multiples above $500,000 of not less than $1,000 each.
291          (d) (i) Without any further election or consent of property owners or registered voters,
292     a public infrastructure district may convert a limited tax bond described in Subsection (3)(a) to
293     a general obligation bond if the principal amount of the related limited tax bond together with
294     the principal amount of other related outstanding general obligation bonds of the public
295     infrastructure district does not exceed 15% of the fair market value of taxable property in the
296     public improvement district securing the general obligation bonds, determined by:
297          (A) an appraisal from an appraiser who is a member of the Appraisal Institute that is
298     addressed to the public infrastructure district or a financial institution; or
299          (B) the most recent market value of the property from the assessor of the county in
300     which the property is located.
301          (ii) The consent to the issuance of a limited tax bond described in Subsection (3)(a) is
302     sufficient to meet any statutory or constitutional election requirement necessary for the
303     issuance of the limited tax bond and any general obligation bond to be issued in place of the
304     limited tax bond upon meeting the requirements of this Subsection (3)(d).

305          (iii) A general obligation bond resulting from a conversion of a limited tax bond under
306     this Subsection (3)(d) is not subject to the limitation on general obligation bonds described in
307     Subsection 17B-1-1102(4)(a)(xii).
308          (e) A public infrastructure district that levies a property tax for payment of debt service
309     on a limited tax bond issued under this section is not required to comply with the notice and
310     hearing requirements of Section 59-2-919 unless the rate exceeds the rate established in:
311          (i) Section 17B-2a-1209, except as provided in Subsection (8);
312          (ii) the governing document; or
313          (iii) the documents relating to the issuance of the limited tax bond.
314          (4) There is no limitation on the duration of revenues that a public infrastructure
315     district may receive to cover any shortfall in the payment of principal of and interest on a bond
316     that the public infrastructure district issues.
317          (5) A public infrastructure district is not a municipal corporation for purposes of the
318     debt limitation of Utah Constitution, Article XIV, Section 4.
319          (6) The board may, by resolution, delegate to one or more officers of the public
320     infrastructure district the authority to:
321          (a) in accordance and within the parameters set forth in a resolution adopted in
322     accordance with Section 11-14-302, approve the final interest rate, price, principal amount,
323     maturity, redemption features, and other terms of the bond;
324          (b) approve and execute any document relating to the issuance of a bond; and
325          (c) approve any contract related to the acquisition and construction of the
326     improvements, facilities, or property to be financed with a bond.
327          (7) (a) Any person may contest the legality of the issuance of a public infrastructure
328     district bond or any provisions for the security and payment of the bond for a period of 30 days
329     after:
330          (i) publication of the resolution authorizing the bond; or
331          (ii) publication of a notice of bond containing substantially the items required under
332     Subsection 11-14-316(2).
333          (b) After the 30-day period described in Subsection (7)(a), no person may bring a
334     lawsuit or other proceeding contesting the regularity, formality, or legality of the bond for any
335     reason.

336          (8) (a) In the event of any statutory change in the methodology of assessment or
337     collection of property taxes in a manner that reduces the amounts which are devoted or pledged
338     to the repayment of limited tax bonds, a public infrastructure district may charge a rate
339     sufficient to receive the amount of property taxes or assessment the public infrastructure
340     district would have received before the statutory change in order to pay the debt service on
341     outstanding limited tax bonds.
342          (b) The rate increase described in Subsection (8)(a) may exceed the limit described in
343     Section 17B-2a-1209.
344          (c) The public infrastructure district may charge the rate increase described in
345     Subsection (8)(a) until the bonds, including any associated refunding bonds, or other securities,
346     together with applicable interest, are fully met and discharged.