1     
WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING INCENTIVES

2     
2023 GENERAL SESSION

3     
STATE OF UTAH

4     
Chief Sponsor: Scott D. Sandall

5     
House Sponsor: Doug Owens

6     

7     LONG TITLE
8     General Description:
9          This bill addresses efficient use of water including incentives to install and maintain
10     water efficient landscaping.
11     Highlighted Provisions:
12          This bill:
13          ▸     defines terms;
14          ▸     authorizes water conservancy districts to receive grants to provide incentives;
15          ▸     provides conditions on when an owner may receive an incentive;
16          ▸     addresses rulemaking authority;
17          ▸     addresses tracking of local government implementation of water use efficiency
18     standards; and
19          ▸     makes technical and conforming changes.
20     Money Appropriated in this Bill:
21          This bill appropriates in fiscal year 2024:
22          ▸     to the Department of Natural Resources - Water Resources, as an ongoing
23     appropriation:
24               •     from the General Fund, $3,000,000; and
25          ▸     to the Department of Natural Resources - Water Resources, as a one-time
26     appropriation:
27               •     from the General Fund, One-time, $11,200.
28     Other Special Clauses:
29          This bill provides a special effective date.

30     Utah Code Sections Affected:
31     AMENDS:
32          10-9a-536, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2022, Chapter 230
33          17-27a-532, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2022, Chapter 230
34          73-10-37, as enacted by Laws of Utah 2022, Chapter 50
35     

36     Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
37          Section 1. Section 10-9a-536 is amended to read:
38          10-9a-536. Water wise landscaping.
39          (1) As used in this section:
40          (a) "Lawn or turf" means nonagricultural land planted in closely mowed, managed
41     grasses.
42          (b) "Mulch" means material such as rock, bark, wood chips, or other materials left
43     loose and applied to the soil.
44          (c) "Overhead spray irrigation" means above ground irrigation heads that spray water
45     through a nozzle.
46          (d) (i) "Vegetative coverage" means the ground level surface area covered by the
47     exposed leaf area of a plant or group of plants at full maturity.
48          (ii) "Vegetative coverage" does not mean the ground level surface area covered by the
49     exposed leaf area of a tree or trees.
50          (e) "Water wise landscaping" means any or all of the following:
51          (i) installation of plant materials suited to the microclimate and soil conditions that
52     can:
53          (A) remain healthy with minimal irrigation once established; or
54          (B) be maintained without the use of overhead spray irrigation;
55          (ii) use of water for outdoor irrigation through proper and efficient irrigation design
56     and water application; or
57          (iii) use of other landscape design features that:

58          (A) minimize the need of the landscape for supplemental water from irrigation; or
59          (B) reduce the landscape area dedicated to lawn or turf.
60          (2) A municipality may not enact or enforce an ordinance, resolution, or policy that
61     prohibits, or has the effect of prohibiting, a property owner from incorporating water wise
62     landscaping on the property owner's property.
63          (3) (a) Subject to Subsection (3)(b), Subsection (2) does not prohibit a municipality
64     from requiring a property owner to:
65          (i) comply with a site plan review or other review process before installing water wise
66     landscaping;
67          (ii) maintain plant material in a healthy condition; and
68          (iii) follow specific water wise landscaping design requirements adopted by the
69     municipality, including a requirement that:
70          (A) restricts or clarifies the use of mulches considered detrimental to municipal
71     operations;
72          (B) imposes minimum or maximum vegetative coverage standards; or
73          (C) restricts or prohibits the use of specific plant materials.
74          (b) A municipality may not require a property owner to install or keep in place lawn or
75     turf in an area with a width less than eight feet.
76          (4) A municipality shall report to the Division of Water Resources the existence,
77     enactment, or modification of an ordinance, resolution, or policy that implements
78     regional-based water use efficiency standards established by the Division of Water Resources
79     by rule under Section 73-10-37.
80          Section 2. Section 17-27a-532 is amended to read:
81          17-27a-532. Water wise landscaping.
82          (1) As used in this section:
83          (a) "Lawn or turf" means nonagricultural land planted in closely mowed, managed
84     grasses.
85          (b) "Mulch" means material such as rock, bark, wood chips, or other materials left

86     loose and applied to the soil.
87          (c) "Overhead spray irrigation" means above ground irrigation heads that spray water
88     through a nozzle.
89          (d) (i) "Vegetative coverage" means the ground level surface area covered by the
90     exposed leaf area of a plant or group of plants at full maturity.
91          (ii) "Vegetative coverage" does not mean the ground level surface area covered by the
92     exposed leaf area of a tree or trees.
93          (e) "Water wise landscaping" means any or all of the following:
94          (i) installation of plant materials suited to the microclimate and soil conditions that
95     can:
96          (A) remain healthy with minimal irrigation once established; or
97          (B) be maintained without the use of overhead spray irrigation;
98          (ii) use of water for outdoor irrigation through proper and efficient irrigation design
99     and water application; or
100          (iii) the use of other landscape design features that:
101          (A) minimize the need of the landscape for supplemental water from irrigation; or
102          (B) reduce the landscape area dedicated to lawn or turf.
103          (2) A county may not enact or enforce an ordinance, resolution, or policy that prohibits,
104     or has the effect of prohibiting, a property owner from incorporating water wise landscaping on
105     the property owner's property.
106          (3) (a) Subject to Subsection (3)(b), Subsection (2) does not prohibit a county from
107     requiring a property owner to:
108          (i) comply with a site plan review or other review process before installing water wise
109     landscaping;
110          (ii) maintain plant material in a healthy condition; and
111          (iii) follow specific water wise landscaping design requirements adopted by the county,
112     including a requirement that:
113          (A) restricts or clarifies the use of mulches considered detrimental to county

114     operations;
115          (B) imposes minimum or maximum vegetative coverage standards; or
116          (C) restricts or prohibits the use of specific plant materials.
117          (b) A county may not require a property owner to install or keep in place lawn or turf in
118     an area with a width less than eight feet.
119          (4) A county shall report to the Division of Water Resources the existence, enactment,
120     or modification of an ordinance, resolution, or policy that implements regional-based water use
121     efficiency standards established by the Division of Water Resources by rule under Section
122     73-10-37.
123          Section 3. Section 73-10-37 is amended to read:
124          73-10-37. Incentives to use water efficient landscaping.
125          (1) As used in this section:
126          (a) "District" means a water conservancy district, as that term is defined in Section
127     73-10-32.
128          (b) "Division" means the Division of Water Resources.
129          (c) "Landscaping conversion incentive program" means a program administered by a
130     district that pays an owner a financial incentive to remove lawn or turf from a project area on
131     land owned by the owner.
132          [(b)] (d) (i) Except as provided in Subsection [(1)(b)(ii)] (1)(d)(ii), "lawn or turf"
133     means nonagricultural land planted in closely mowed, managed grasses.
134          (ii) "Lawn or turf" does not include a golf course, park, athletic field, or sod farm.
135          [(c)] (e) "Owner" means an owner of private or public land where a water end user is
136     located.
137          (f) "Program guidelines" means guidelines adopted by a district for the district's
138     landscaping conversion incentive program.
139          (g) "Project area" means the area from which lawn or turf is removed and replaced with
140     water efficient landscaping.
141          [(d)] (h) "Water end user" means a person who enters into a water contract to obtain

142     water from a retail water provider for residential, commercial, industrial, or institutional use.
143          (2) [(a) Subject to a $5,000,000 aggregate annual cap, the] The division may:
144          (a) award a grant under Subsection (3) to a district to fund financial incentives
145     provided through a landscaping conversion incentive program administered by the district; and
146          (b) provide an incentive under Subsection (4) to an owner to remove lawn or turf from
147     a project area on land owned by the owner in an area without a landscaping conversion
148     incentive program.
149          (3) (a) (i) A district may obtain a grant from the division to help fund a financial
150     incentive provided to an owner through a landscaping conversion incentive program
151     administered by the district.
152          (ii) Both the award and use of a grant under this Subsection (3) are subject to
153     Subsections (3)(b), (c), and (d).
154          (b) To obtain a grant, a district shall:
155          (i) initiate and operate a landscaping conversion incentive program;
156          (ii) limit the disbursement of grant money in the district's landscaping conversion
157     incentive program to owners that satisfy the minimum requirements of Subsection (4)(c) and:
158          (A) rules made by the division under Subsection (5)(b); or
159          (B) program guidelines approved by the division under Subsection (3)(f);
160          (iii) use the grant exclusively to fund financial incentives provided to owners that
161     remove lawn or turf from a project area in the district's landscaping conversion incentive
162     program;
163          (iv) provide an equal amount or more of matching funds for the district's landscaping
164     conversion incentive program from sources other than the grant money the district receives
165     under this section;
166          (v) file an application with the division that:
167          (A) describes the district's landscaping conversion incentive program, including
168     verification that the program can and shall implement the minimum requirements of
169     Subsection (4)(c) and either rules made by the division under Subsection (5)(b) or program

170     guidelines approved by the division under Subsection (3)(f);
171          (B) includes a copy of the program guidelines governing the district's landscaping
172     conversion incentive program;
173          (C) if the district wants to be subject to program guidelines in lieu of division rules
174     made under Subsection (5)(b), requests that the division approve the district's program
175     guidelines under Subsection (3)(f); and
176          (D) provides additional information requested by the division; and
177          (vi) enter into a contract with the division that requires the district to:
178          (A) verify that participants comply and landscaping conversion projects proposed,
179     undertaken, and completed by participants under the district's landscaping conversion incentive
180     program satisfy the requirements in this Subsection (3) and any contract before using grant
181     money for a financial incentive;
182          (B) agree not to use grant money for a financial incentive in any landscaping
183     conversion project that fails to satisfy the requirements of this Subsection (3) and either rules
184     made by the division or program guidelines approved by the division under Subsection (3)(f);
185          (C) submit to the division quarterly reports on funding status; and
186          (D) prepare and submit an annual accounting to the division on the use of grant money
187     for financial incentives in the district's landscaping conversion incentive program.
188          (c) (i) Upon expenditure of 70% of the grant money awarded to a district and an
189     accounting on the use of that grant money, a district may apply for additional grant money in
190     accordance with Subsection (3)(b).
191          (ii) The division may award a district an additional grant based on:
192          (A) the availability of grant money;
193          (B) the priority or importance of the grant proposal in relation to availability of grant
194     money, the division's landscaping conversion incentive program under this Subsection (3),
195     other landscaping conversion incentive program grant requests, and regional needs and goals;
196          (C) the effectiveness of the district's landscaping conversion incentive program in
197     incentivizing owners to convert lawn or turf to water efficient landscaping;

198          (D) the district's previous compliance with this Subsection (3) and contract terms and
199     conditions; and
200          (E) any matter bearing on the district's ability to responsibly handle and disperse grant
201     money consistent with this Subsection (3) and contract terms and conditions.
202          (d) A district awarded grant money under this Subsection (3) may not use grant money
203     to pay an incentive that exceeds the maximum amounts established by the division by rule
204     under Subsection (5)(c).
205          (e) Nothing in this section prohibits a district from expending non-grant money,
206     including matching money, under the district's landscaping conversion incentive program to:
207          (i) assist an owner that does not satisfy Subsection (4)(c); or
208          (ii) provide an incentive that exceeds a maximum amount established by the division
209     for grant money under Subsection (3)(d).
210          (f) The division may approve a request from a district under Subsection (3)(b)(v)(C) to
211     use program guidelines in lieu of rules made by the division under Subsection (5)(b) if the
212     division determines that the district's program guidelines will:
213          (i) result in at least as much water use savings as rules made under Subsection (5)(b);
214     and
215          (ii) accomplish the same objectives as rules made under Subsection (5)(b).
216          (4) (a) In an area without an existing landscaping conversion incentive program, the
217     division may provide an incentive to an owner to remove lawn or turf from land owned by the
218     owner and replace the lawn or turf with [drought resistant] water efficient landscaping.
219          (b) If the division provides an incentive under this [section] Subsection (4), the
220     division shall provide the incentive in the order that an application for the incentive is filed.
221     The division may terminate an application if the division determines that the owner has not
222     completed the project within 12 months of the date on which the owner files the application for
223     the incentive.
224          (c) To be eligible for an incentive under this [section,] Subsection (4):
225          (i) the owner shall at the time the owner applies for the incentive:

226          [(i)] (A) have living lawn or turf, as determined by the entity providing the incentive,
227     on the land owned by the owner that the owner intends to replace with [drought resistant] water
228     efficient landscaping; and
229          [(ii) be in good standing with a retail water provider so that the owner has no unpaid
230     water bills; and]
231          [(iii)] (B) participate voluntarily in the removal of the lawn or turf in that the removal
232     is not required by governmental code or policy[.];
233          (ii) the property where the project area is located, is located within:
234          (A) a municipality that implements regional-based water use efficiency standards
235     established by the division under Subsection (5)(d); or
236          (B) an unincorporated area of a county that implements regional-based water use
237     efficiency standards established by the division under Subsection (5)(d); and
238          (iii) the owner shall agree to:
239          (A) maintain water efficient landscaping and a drip irrigation system installed in the
240     project area and not reinstall lawn or turf or overhead spray irrigation in the project area after
241     receipt of a payment under this section to incentivize conversion of lawn or turf to water
242     efficient landscaping; or
243          (B) return to the division or to a district the payments received for removal of lawn or
244     turf from the project area.
245          (d) An owner may not receive an incentive under this section if the owner has
246     previously received an incentive under this section for the same [property] project area.
247          (e) [The division may not provide an owner] An owner may not receive an incentive
248     under this [section] Subsection (4) in an amount [greater than 50% of the cost of replacing the]
249     that exceeds:
250          (i) the maximum amount established by the division in rule, as provided in Subsection
251     (5) for each square foot of lawn or turf [with drought resistant] converted to water efficient
252     landscaping; or
253          (ii) the maximum aggregate amount established by the division in rule as provided in

254     Subsection (5).
255          [(3)] (5) The division [may] shall make rules, in accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3,
256     Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act:
257          (a) establishing the process by which:
258          (i) a district obtains a grant under Subsection (3); or
259          (ii) an owner obtains an incentive under [this section; and] Subsection (4);
260          (b) defining what constitutes [drought resistant] water efficient landscaping[.],
261     including what irrigation is used after conversion to water efficient landscaping;
262          (c) establishing for funding under this section, the maximum incentive from grant
263     money allowable for each square foot of lawn or turf converted to water efficient landscaping
264     or a maximum aggregate amount; and
265          (d) establishing for purposes of this section regional-based water use efficiency
266     standards designed to reduce water consumption and conserve culinary and secondary water
267     supplies.
268          (6) This section does not prohibit a municipality or county from adopting landscaping
269     standards that would result in greater water efficiency than provided by division rule made
270     under Subsection (5) if the standards do not conflict with this section or division rules.
271          (7) The division shall maintain a public website that, at a minimum, provides the status
272     of a municipal or county ordinance, resolution, or policy that implements regional-based water
273     use efficiency standards as described in Subsection (4)(c)(ii).
274          Section 4. Appropriation.
275          The following sums of money are appropriated for the fiscal year beginning July 1,
276     2023, and ending June 30, 2024. These are additions to amounts previously appropriated for
277     fiscal year 2024. Under the terms and conditions of Title 63J, Chapter 1, Budgetary Procedures
278     Act, the Legislature appropriates the following sums of money from the funds or accounts
279     indicated for the use and support of the government of the state of Utah.
280     ITEM 1
281     To Department of Natural Resources - Water Resources

282          From General Fund
3,000,000

283          From General Fund, One-time
11,200

284          Schedule of Programs:
285               Planning                                   3,011,200
286          The Legislature intends that the Division of Water Resources use the $3,000,000
287     ongoing appropriation for incentives to use water efficient landscaping as outlined in Section
288     73-10-37.
289          Section 5. Effective date.
290          If approved by two-thirds of all the members elected to each house, this bill takes effect
291     upon approval by the governor, or the day following the constitutional time limit of Utah
292     Constitution, Article VII, Section 8, without the governor's signature, or in the case of a veto,
293     the date of veto override.