Representative Stephanie Gricius proposes the following substitute bill:


1     
WILDLIFE HUNTING AMENDMENTS

2     
2024 GENERAL SESSION

3     
STATE OF UTAH

4     
Chief Sponsor: Stephanie Gricius

5     
Senate Sponsor: Curtis S. Bramble

6     

7     LONG TITLE
8     General Description:
9          This bill modifies provisions related to big game.
10     Highlighted Provisions:
11          This bill:
12          ▸     moves definitions to the provision applicable to a chapter;
13          ▸     addresses what is sufficient wearing of hunter orange while hunting big game;
14          ▸     grants the director of the Division of Wildlife Resources authority related to the
15     wearing of hunter orange by non-hunters;
16          ▸     addresses the commercial use of big game byproducts, including the payment of
17     royalties; and
18          ▸     makes technical changes.
19     Money Appropriated in this Bill:
20          None
21     Other Special Clauses:
22          None
23     Utah Code Sections Affected:
24     AMENDS:
25          23A-3-201, as renumbered and amended by Laws of Utah 2023, Chapter 103

26          23A-11-101, as renumbered and amended by Laws of Utah 2023, Chapter 103
27          23A-11-205, as renumbered and amended by Laws of Utah 2023, Chapter 103
28     ENACTS:
29          23A-11-303, Utah Code Annotated 1953
30          59-31-101, Utah Code Annotated 1953
31          59-31-102, Utah Code Annotated 1953
32          59-31-103, Utah Code Annotated 1953
33          59-31-201, Utah Code Annotated 1953
34          59-31-202, Utah Code Annotated 1953
35     

36     Be it enacted by the Legislature of the state of Utah:
37          Section 1. Section 23A-3-201 is amended to read:
38          23A-3-201. Wildlife Resources Account -- Unexpected fund balances converted to
39     General Fund account.
40          (1) There is created a restricted account within the General Fund known as the
41     "Wildlife Resources Account."
42          (2) The following money shall be deposited into the Wildlife Resources Account:
43          (a) revenue from the sale of licenses, permits, tags, and certificates of registration
44     issued under this title or a rule or proclamation of the Wildlife Board, except as otherwise
45     provided by this title;
46          (b) revenue from the sale, lease, rental, or other granting of rights of real or personal
47     property acquired with revenue specified in Subsection (2)(a);
48          (c) revenue from fines and forfeitures for violations of this title or a rule, proclamation,
49     or order of the Wildlife Board, minus court costs not to exceed the schedule adopted by the
50     Judicial Council;
51          (d) revenue deposited into the fund under Title 59, Chapter 31, Big Game Byproduct
52     Royalty;
53          [(d)] (e) money appropriated from the General Fund by the Legislature pursuant to
54     Section 23A-4-306;
55          [(e)] (f) other money received by the division under this title, except as otherwise
56     provided by this title; and

57          [(f)] (g) interest, dividends, or other income earned on account money.
58          (3) Money in the Wildlife Resources Account shall be used for the administration of
59     this title.
60          (4) The state auditor and director of the Division of Finance shall, at the close of the
61     fiscal year, convert into the Wildlife Resources Account the unexpended balances of the
62     Wildlife Resources Account not legally obligated by contract or appropriated by the Wildlife
63     Board for capital outlay projects or other programs that may extend beyond the close of the
64     fiscal year.
65          Section 2. Section 23A-11-101 is amended to read:
66          23A-11-101. Definitions.
67          As used in this chapter:
68          (1) "Big game" includes deer, elk, big horn sheep, moose, mountain goats, pronghorn,
69     and bison.
70          (2) (a) "Big game byproduct" means those parts of the carcass of a lawfully taken big
71     game animal that are listed in Subsections (2)(a)(i) through (ix):
72          (i) bones with less than 1/2 inch of attached muscle tissue;
73          (ii) fat, tendons, ligaments, cartilage, and silverskin with less than 1/2 inch attached
74     muscle tissue;
75          (iii) muscle tissue damaged by wound channels and within one inch of damaged tissue;
76          (iv) head;
77          (v) rib and neck meat on deer, pronghorn, mountain goat, and bighorn sheep;
78          (vi) antlers and horns;
79          (vii) legs below the knee and hock;
80          (viii) internal organs; and
81          (ix) hide.
82          (b) Notwithstanding Subsection (2)(a), "big game byproduct" does not include:
83          (i) brain or brain tissue;
84          (ii) spine or any part of the spinal column;
85          (iii) any portion of the carcass of an animal testing positive for chronic wasting disease;
86          (iv) any carcass or portion of a carcass that otherwise fails to meet local, state, or
87     federal regulations governing processing, sale, or distribution of wild game; and

88          (v) spoiled product.
89          (3) (a) "Centerfire rifle hunt" means a hunt for which a hunter may use a centerfire
90     rifle, except as provided in Subsection (3)(b).
91          (b) "Centerfire rifle hunt" does not include:
92          (i) a bighorn sheep hunt;
93          (ii) a mountain goat hunt;
94          (iii) a bison hunt;
95          (iv) a moose hunt;
96          (v) a hunt requiring the hunter to possess a statewide conservation permit; or
97          (vi) a hunt requiring the hunter to possess a statewide sportsman permit.
98          [(2)] (4) "Cultivated crops" means:
99          (a) annual or perennial crops harvested from or on cleared and planted land;
100          (b) perennial orchard trees on cleared and planted land;
101          (c) crop residues that have forage value for livestock; and
102          (d) pastures.
103          (5) "Financial advantage" means an act through which a person in lawful possession of
104     a protected wildlife carcass uses or disposes of that carcass or carcass parts in a transaction for
105     which the person receives consideration or expects to recover associated costs.
106          [(3)] (6) "Management unit" means a prescribed area of contiguous land designated by
107     the division for the purpose of managing a species of big game animal.
108          [(4)] (7) "Predator" means a cougar, bear, or coyote.
109          (8) "Spoiled product" means any portion of a protected wildlife carcass that is not fit
110     for human or animal consumption due to the presence of parasites, pathogens, or rot.
111          (9) "Statewide conservation permit" means a permit:
112          (a) issued by the division;
113          (b) distributed through a nonprofit organization founded for the purpose of promoting
114     wildlife conservation; and
115          (c) valid:
116          (i) on open hunting units statewide; and
117          (ii) for the species of big game and time period designated by the Wildlife Board.
118          (10) "Statewide sportsman permit" means a permit:

119          (a) issued by the division through a public draw; and
120          (b) valid:
121          (i) on open hunting units statewide; and
122          (ii) for the species of big game and time period designated by the Wildlife Board.
123          Section 3. Section 23A-11-205 is amended to read:
124          23A-11-205. Requirement to wear hunter orange -- Exceptions -- Nonhunters.
125          [(1) As used in this section:]
126          [(a) (i) "Centerfire rifle hunt" means a hunt for which a hunter may use a centerfire
127     rifle, except as provided in Subsection (1)(a)(ii).]
128          [(ii) "Centerfire rifle hunt" does not include:]
129          [(A) a bighorn sheep hunt;]
130          [(B) a mountain goat hunt;]
131          [(C) a bison hunt;]
132          [(D) a moose hunt;]
133          [(E) a hunt requiring the hunter to possess a statewide conservation permit; or]
134          [(F) a hunt requiring the hunter to possess a statewide sportsman permit.]
135          [(b) "Statewide conservation permit" means a permit:]
136          [(i) issued by the division;]
137          [(ii) distributed through a nonprofit organization founded for the purpose of promoting
138     wildlife conservation; and]
139          [(iii) valid:]
140          [(A) on open hunting units statewide; and]
141          [(B) for the species of big game and time period designated by the Wildlife Board.]
142          [(c) "Statewide sportsman permit" means a permit:]
143          [(i) issued by the division through a public draw; and]
144          [(ii) valid:]
145          [(A) on open hunting units statewide; and]
146          [(B) for the species of big game and time period designated by the Wildlife Board.]
147          [(2) (a) A person]
148          (1) An individual while hunting a species of big game shall wear [a minimum of 400
149     square inches of hunter orange material while hunting a species of big game], on the exterior so

150     the item can be seen, one or more of the following items that are primarily hunter orange
151     material, except as provided in Subsection [(3).] (2):
152          (a) a hat;
153          (b) a shirt;
154          (c) a jacket;
155          (d) a coat;
156          (e) a vest; or
157          (f) a sweater.
158          [(b) A person shall wear hunter orange material on the head, chest, and back.]
159          [(3) A person]
160          (2) An individual is not required to wear [the] a hunter orange [material] item
161     described in Subsection [(2)] (1):
162          (a) during the following types of hunts, unless a centerfire rifle hunt is in progress in
163     the same area:
164          (i) archery;
165          (ii) muzzle-loader;
166          (iii) mountain goat;
167          (iv) bighorn sheep;
168          (v) bison; or
169          (vi) moose; or
170          (b) as provided by a rule of the Wildlife Board made in accordance with Title 63G,
171     Chapter 3, Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act.
172          (3) (a) The director may regulate the wearing of hunter orange by an individual who is:
173          (i) not hunting, such as a hiker, camper, or other recreational user; and
174          (ii) accessing a wildlife management area while a centerfire rifle hunt for big game is
175     in progress on the wildlife management area.
176          (b) Notwithstanding Subsection (3)(a), the director may not regulate the wearing of
177     hunter orange under this Subsection (3) by a landowner owning land inside a wildlife
178     management area or by the landowner's immediate family members.
179          (4) An individual engaged in agriculture activities is not subject to the requirements to
180     wear hunter orange under this section.

181          Section 4. Section 23A-11-303 is enacted to read:
182          23A-11-303. Big game byproduct.
183          (1) (a) Except as provided in Subsection (1)(f), a person shall obtain a certificate of
184     registration from the division to purchase, acquire, sell, barter, exchange, or trade big game
185     byproduct for financial advantage.
186          (b) To obtain a certificate of registration authorizing the purchase, sale, barter, or trade
187     of big game byproduct for financial advantage, the applicant shall:
188          (i) operate a licensed meat processing business in compliance with state and local
189     government wild game processing laws; and
190          (ii) (A) provide proof of engagement in the sale of big game byproduct before July 1,
191     2023, and have processed 500 big game animals in three out of the five consecutive calendar
192     years preceding application; or
193          (B) have processed 800 big game animals in three out of the five consecutive calendar
194     years preceding application.
195          (c) A person receiving a certificate of registration under this section shall:
196          (i) post signage in a conspicuous location of the person's business indicating the
197     person's involvement in the program regulated by this section;
198          (ii) test incoming deer, elk, and moose carcasses from the following areas for chronic
199     wasting disease:
200          (A) a state or province, other than Utah, where chronic wasting disease has been
201     detected in big game; or
202          (B) a management unit within the state that the division has designated as endemic for
203     chronic wasting disease;
204          (iii) subject to Subsection (1)(d), receive a negative test result for chronic wasting
205     disease before selling, bartering, exchanging, or trading big game byproduct from tested
206     carcasses to another person;
207          (iv) be subject to reasonable inspections of facilities that process or sell, barter,
208     exchange, or trade big game byproduct and relevant records;
209          (v) record and upon request of the division, provide the following for a big game
210     animal received:
211          (A) permit holder's name;

212          (B) permit holder's phone number;
213          (C) state for which the permit was issued;
214          (D) permit number;
215          (E) date animal was received by the processing facility;
216          (F) species associated with the permit;
217          (G) total weight of carcass, in pounds, upon arrival at the processing facility;
218          (H) weight of product, in pounds, returned to the hunter; and
219          (I) the date the certificate of registration holder submits a deer, elk, or moose carcass
220     for testing for chronic wasting disease;
221          (vi) retain records detailed in Subsection (1)(c)(v) for two years;
222          (vii) report to the division the total number of pounds of big game byproduct sold,
223     bartered, exchanged, or traded each tax year on or before the April 15 immediately following
224     the last day of that tax year; and
225          (viii) pay a royalty on the total number of pounds of big game byproduct sold, bartered,
226     exchanged, or traded each calendar year, as prescribed in Title 59, Chapter 31, Big Game
227     Byproduct Royalty.
228          (d) Notwithstanding Subsection (1)(c)(iii), a certificate of registration holder may sell,
229     barter, exchange, or trade big game byproducts if the big game byproduct is:
230          (i) not required to be tested under this section; or
231          (ii) required to be tested under this section but a lab result is not provided to the
232     certificate of registration holder within six months from the date the test sample was submitted.
233          (e) (i) The certificate of registration holder is responsible for the costs associated with
234     laboratory testing for chronic wasting disease of deer, elk, and moose carcasses from
235     out-of-state hunters, except that the certificate of registration holder may pass the cost of
236     testing to the out-of-state hunter that provides the big game byproduct.
237          (ii) The division is responsible for the costs associated with laboratory testing for
238     chronic wasting disease for deer, elk, and moose carcasses from hunters within the state, with
239     the costs being paid from the royalty revenue collected under Title 59, Chapter 31, Big Game
240     Byproduct Royalty.
241          (f) A person may purchase, acquire, sell, barter, exchange, or trade big game byproduct
242     for financial advantage without a certificate of registration, provided the big game byproduct is:

243          (i) (A) processed and individually packaged for the big game byproduct's intended end
244     use when purchased, acquired, sold, bartered, exchanged, or traded; or
245          (ii) otherwise authorized for purchase, sale, offer or possessed for sale, barter,
246     exchange, or trade by statute or administrative rule.
247          (2) Except as otherwise authorized in this title, rule, or proclamation, a person may not
248     in violation of Section 23A-5-304, purchase, sell, barter, exchange, or trade any other species
249     of lawfully taken protected wildlife or wildlife parts for financial advantage.
250          (3) A certificate of registration holder agrees to abide by applicable state and federal
251     laws.
252          (4) For a carcass testing positive for chronic wasting disease under Subsection (1)(c)
253     and that is surrendered to the division by the hunter, the person named on the certificate of
254     registration under this section may donate unclaimed processed wildlife to the client that is
255     reasonably equivalent in value to the product surrendered to the division.
256          (5) The Wildlife Board may make rules, in accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3, Utah
257     Administrative Rulemaking Act, to enforce and administer this section.
258          Section 5. Section 59-31-101 is enacted to read:
259     
CHAPTER 31. BIG GAME BYPRODUCT ROYALTY

260     
Part 1. General Provisions

261          59-31-101. Definitions.
262          As used in this chapter:
263          (1) "Big game byproduct" means the same as that term is defined in Section
264     23A-11-101.
265          (2) "Tax year" means a one-year period beginning on April 1 and ending on March 31
266     of the following year,
267          Section 6. Section 59-31-102 is enacted to read:
268          59-31-102. Rulemaking.
269          In accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3, Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act, the
270     commission may make rules to implement and enforce this chapter.
271          Section 7. Section 59-31-103 is enacted to read:
272          59-31-103. Penalties.
273          A person who sells, barters, exchanges, or trades big game byproduct under Section

274     23A-11-303 and fails to comply with this chapter is subject to penalties and interest as
275     provided in Sections 59-1-401 and 59-1-402.
276          Section 8. Section 59-31-201 is enacted to read:
277     
Part 2. Big Game Byproduct Royalty Payments

278          59-31-201. Big game byproduct royalty -- Royalty rate -- Commission to prepare
279     billing statement -- Deposit of revenue.
280          (1) A person shall pay for each tax year, a royalty of six cents multiplied by the total
281     number of pounds of big game byproduct sold, bartered, exchanged, or traded under authority
282     of a certificate of registration issued by the Division of Wildlife Resources under Section
283     23A-11-303.
284          (2) (a) A person that holds a certificate of registration to sell, barter, exchange, or trade
285     big game byproduct under Section 23A-11-303 shall report to the Division of Wildlife
286     Resources the total number of pounds of big game byproduct sold, bartered, exchanged, or
287     traded by that person for that tax year on or before the April 15 immediately following the last
288     day of that tax year.
289          (b) The Division of Wildlife Resources shall provide the Department of Natural
290     Resources each tax year the data received under Subsection (2)(a).
291          (c) The Department of Natural Resources shall provide the following information to
292     the commission on or before the May 1 immediately following the last day of a tax year:
293          (i) the total number of pounds of big game byproduct sold, bartered, exchanged, or
294     traded that tax year under a certificate of registration; and
295          (ii) for each person that sold, bartered, exchanged, or traded big game byproduct under
296     a certificate of registration for that tax year:
297          (A) the total number of pounds of big game byproduct sold, bartered, exchanged, or
298     traded by that person for that tax year; and
299          (B) a current billing address for that person; and
300          (iii) any additional information required by the commission.
301          (3) (a) The commission shall prepare and mail a billing statement to each person that
302     sold, bartered, exchanged, or traded big game byproduct in a tax year by May 30 immediately
303     following the last day of a tax year.
304          (b) The billing statement under Subsection (3)(a) shall specify:

305          (i) the total number of pounds of big game byproduct reported sold, bartered,
306     exchanged, or traded by that person for that tax year;
307          (ii) the big game byproduct royalty that the person owes; and
308          (iii) the date that the big game byproduct royalty payment is due, as provided in
309     Section 59-31-202.
310          (c) In accordance with Title 63G, Chapter 3, Utah Administrative Rulemaking Act, the
311     commission may make rules prescribing the information required under Subsection (2)(c)(iii).
312          (4) The commission shall deposit revenue generated by the big game byproduct royalty
313     into the Wildlife Resources Account created in Section 23A-3-201.
314          Section 9. Section 59-31-202 is enacted to read:
315          59-31-202. Payment of royalty.
316          (1) A person who sells, barters, exchanges, or trades big game byproduct shall pay a
317     big game byproduct royalty pursuant to this chapter.
318          (2) A person paying a big game byproduct royalty shall include with the royalty
319     payment the billing statement prepared by the commission in accordance with Section
320     59-31-201.
321          (3) A big game byproduct royalty payment is due on the June 30 immediately
322     following the last day of the tax year.
323          Section 10. Effective date.
324          This bill takes effect on May 1, 2024.